12th edition

2023 Yearbook of Case Law

The 12th edition of the Yearbook of European Case Law on Industrial and Intellectual Property analyzes 13 significant 2023 court decisions on trademarks, copyrights, patents, designs, piracy, and plant varieties, featuring commentary from ELZABURU professionals and offering a practical and specialized perspective.
Pages
76
Cases
13
Authors
9
Languages
ES - EN

About This Edition

The 12th edition of the Yearbook of European Case Law on Industrial and Intellectual Property compiles and analyzes 13 selected rulings from 2023, handed down by the Court of Justice of the European Union and by Spanish courts. The publication addresses relevant issues in the areas of trademarks, copyright and the information society, patents, designs, piracy, and plant varieties.

Among the topics analyzed are initial civil appeals against decisions by the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM), judicial jurisdiction in trademark matters, communication to the public and private copying, patent infringement and modification, functionality and visibility in industrial designs, penalties for trademark counterfeiting, and damages for infringement of plant variety rights.

Each decision follows the structure of “Facts,” “Rulings,” and “Commentary,” which provides insight into the origin of the dispute, the criteria adopted by the court, and its main legal and practical implications.

The result is a specialized and practical overview of some of the rulings that have shaped the evolution of industrial and intellectual property in 2023.


Notable Rulings

Chapter 1
Brands
  • The new civil appeal against SPTO decisions granting trademark registration
  • International Jurisdiction in Actions for Violation of a Multilateral Environmental Agreement Brought Against Multiple Defendants Domiciled in Different Member States
  • The “Unrelated” Counterclaim in Trademark Invalidity Actions
Chapter 2
Copyright, Information Society, Internet
  • “Private Copying” and “Public Communication” in a Closed-Circuit Internet Television Service
  • Required Justifications for Granting Preliminary Injunctions Based on Copyright
  • Public Broadcast of Ambient Music on Airplanes and Trains
Chapter 3
Patents
  • Patent and CCP Infringement for Marketing a Generic Drug Before the Expiration of Those Rights
  • Amendment of a European Patent During the Proceedings for a Declaration of Invalidity
Chapter 4
Designs
  • Appearance features of an industrial design dictated exclusively by its technical function
  • Visibility of a component of a complex product during the end consumer's normal use of that product
Chapter 5
Piracy
  • Legality and Proportionality of Criminal Penalties for Trademark Counterfeiting
Chapter 6
Plant varieties
  • Minimum Damages and Punitive Damages in Actions for Infringement of Community Plant Variety Rights