On January 14, 2023, a new regulation governing invalidity and revocation proceedings in Spain will take effect, under which the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM) will have jurisdiction to hear and decide invalidity and revocation proceedings relating to trademark and trade name registrations.
This shift away from court proceedings—which stems from the implementation of Directive 2015/2436 on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to trademarks—means that, as of January 14, such actions for invalidity and revocation may no longer be brought before civil courts, unless they are filed as a counterclaim in an infringement action.
Another new development is that decisions by the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM) that exhaust the administrative remedies will be subject to review by the civil courts—not only those resolving new actions for nullity and lapse, but also those OEPM decisions resolving industrial property rights proceedings, including both applications and oppositions, whether relating to trademarks, trade names, designs, or patents.
This reform is expected to simplify legal actions and procedures, as well as reduce the costs of such procedures.
If you have any questions or would like more information, please contact your usual point of contact or send an email directly to elzaburu@elzaburu.es.
NULLITY
Under what circumstances may a nullity proceeding be initiated?
It may be requested on relative grounds or on absolute grounds.
The relative grounds that may be asserted to seek invalidation are essentially the same as those that may be invoked in opposition proceedings, in particular, prior rights recognized by law.
The absolute groundson which an action for annulment may be based are as follows:
An application for invalidation may be filed against all the goods and services covered by the contested registration or against a portion thereof.
When can a nullity proceeding be initiated?
At any time, bearing in mind that the right to file an application for relative invalidity expires five years from the time the applicant for invalidity became aware of and tolerated the use of the sign sought to be invalidated.
Actions for absolute invalidity, on the other hand, are not subject to a statute of limitations and may therefore be filed at any time after the trademark is registered.
In what cases can this nullity proceeding not be initiated?
A relative nullity proceeding cannot be upheld if:
For its part, proceedings for absolute nullity may not be initiated if:
Who can initiate these nullity proceedings?
Generally speaking, you may file a petition for annulment,
This procedure may be based on one or more prior rights, provided that they belong to the same owner.
What does it mean when a trademark is invalidated by the OEPM?
Except in those cases or circumstances expressly provided for by law, the trademark or trade name is deemed never to have had any legal effect—that is, as if it had never existed.
EXPIRATION DATE
Under what circumstances can one request the administrative revocation of a Spanish trademark or trade name?
The grounds on which a request may be made for the cancellation of a trademark are as follows:
A declaration of expiration may be total or partial, covering all or part of the goods or services identified by the trademark.
Is it possible to start using or resume using a trademark to prevent it from expiring due to nonuse?
Yes, provided that such commencement or resumption does not occur within the three-month period immediately preceding the filing of the application for revocation and the trademark owner was aware that such an application might be filed.
Are there any justifiable reasons for the nonuse of a trademark?
Yes, circumstances beyond the owner’s control—such as import restrictions or other official requirements imposed on the goods or services for which the trademark is registered—will be recognized as justifiable grounds for non-use.
When does the declaration of a trademark's expiration take effect?
By default, the effects of revocation will be retroactive to the date of the revocation request. However, at the request of a party, the decision on the revocation request may set an earlier date on which any of the grounds for revocation mentioned above occurred.
Cristina Velasco, Junior Associate at ELZABURU
Belize, a small country in the northeastern corner of Central America that is a member of the Commonwealth, has English as its official language.
Belize has just announced that it will join the Madrid System effective February 24, 2023. This small Central American country will become the 129th member of the System, which already includes other countries in the Americas such as the United States, Canada, Brazil, Chile, Mexico, Colombia, Jamaica, Samoa, Trinidad and Tobago, Antigua and Barbuda, Cuba, and the former Dutch Antilles.
A Caribbean country with an economy that relies primarily on agriculture (mainly sugar and bananas) and on a growing tourism industry thanks to its idyllic setting, although it is not entirely free from conflict precisely because of its strategic location. It has significant mineral and oil production.
In any case, this is an important jurisdiction for our Spanish clients, who often include it in their trademark protection plans.
There are some unknowns surrounding its incorporation into the Madrid System. The first issue to consider is language. The second is the harmonization of local requirements regarding the declaration of use or non-use mandated by national law. It is likely that it will still be necessary to comply with local formalities even when opting for a form of international protection. In any case, let’s wait for the entry into force to be officially confirmed, and as always, we’ll see how things unfold as we gain practical experience.
Cristina Arroyo, Director of International Brands at ELZABURU
[Background]
In July 2012, Dongfang Mingri (Jinjiang) Import & Export Co. (“Dongfang Mingri”) filed an application to register the word mark “奔富酒园” in Chinese characters (in English: BEN FU WINERY, No. 11157214), which was granted in December 2015, designating, among other things, goods such as “wine, brandy” in Class 33. Following registration, Dongfang Mingri began using the trademark for wine products in the Chinese market.
Southcorp Brands Pty Limited (a subsidiary of Treasury Wine Estates, “Southcorp”) filed an application to invalidate the registration of the contested trademark “奔富酒园” in March 2016, on the grounds that the contested trademark was similar to a sign (“奔富” (pronounced: BEN FU)) that had already been used by certain Southcorp distributors and enjoyed substantial influence, in addition to the fact that the owner of the contested trademark had registered a large number of trademarks that were reproductions, imitations, or translations of well-known third-party trademarks, which was contrary to the principle of good faith.
The Trademark Review and Adjudication Board decided to invalidate the registration of the contested trademark, finding that there was a clear intent to take unfair advantage of the reputation of well-known trademarks, engage in unfair competition, and seek illegal profits, thereby violating the principle of good faith and disrupting the proper administration of the trademark registry and fair and orderly market competition. Dongfang Mingri’s activities were found to constitute“acquisition of a registration by other improper means,”as set forth in Article 44(1) of the Trademark Law of 2014 (unchanged in the 2019 Amendment to the Trademark Law).
The Beijing Intellectual Property Court rejected Dongfang Mingri's appeal, which had been remanded by the Beijing High Court.
The case is finally referred to the Supreme Court of the People's Republic of China.
[Decision]
The Supreme Court first summarized the key issue in the case, which was to determine whether the contested trademark “奔富酒园” had been registered through other improper means, such as those prohibited under Article 44(1) of the Trademark Law of 2014.
At the outset, the Court confirmed that the most relevant element of the contested trademark is the first two Chinese characters, “奔富 (BEN FU)”; the combination of the remaining two Chinese characters, “酒园,” means “winery,” which can only be treated as a common description in the relevant industry.
Southcorp provided sufficient evidence to support its argument that the sign “奔富” was first used by some of Southcorp’s distributors in the 1990s to refer to the “Penfolds” wine brand, a Southcorp product. Furthermore, from the perspective of the relevant public, long before the filing of the contested trademark application, the Chinese characters “奔富 (BEN FU)” had been regarded as a transliteration of “Penfolds” and, as a result, established a strong association with it.
Prior to the case at hand, there had been numerous disputes involving trademark infringement and unfair competition between Southcorp and Dongfang Mingri. Previous rulings had found that Dongfang Mingri and its subsidiaries had intentionally misled the public by using promotional materials for the “Penfolds” wine brand in the media, which constituted unfair competition as well as an infringement of the “PENFOLDS” trademark.
Based on the foregoing analysis, the Court concluded that, by filing the application to register the contested trademark “奔富酒园,” Dongfang Mingri intends to capitalize on the reputation of the “Penfolds” wine producer and gain an unfair advantage over it.
Furthermore, the Court found that the fact that Dongfang Mingri and its subsidiaries had registered a large number (more than 250) of trademarks copied from other well-known trademarks—such as “宾利 (BIN LI, a transliteration of BENTLEY)”—for goods and services in classes 33 and 35 went far beyond what is necessary for a normal business.
[Comments]
From the filing of the petition to invalidate the trademark registration to the issuance of the judgment of invalidity, this case has come to an end after six years.
In the appeal proceedings before the Beijing High Court, the TRAB’s decision and the Beijing Intellectual Property Court’s judgment invalidating the contested trademark were based, among other things, on the fact that the contested trademark had been used in commerce by the owner after registration.
Contrary to the opinion of the Beijing High Court, the Supreme Court clarified the concept of“obtaining registration by fraudulent or other improper means”in Art. 44(1) of the 2014 Trademark Law (there are no changes in the 2019 Amendment to the Trademark Law), holding that it should be interpreted as referring to the means employed when filing the application for registration, rather than the purpose of the registration, which is in itself improper.
Therefore, the fact that the contested trademark was put into use after registration—regardless of the level of advertising investment or the effectiveness of the advertising—cannot negate the “improper” nature of the means used to obtain the registration and, consequently, cannot justify the registration of the trademark.
The ruling reflects the Court’s tendency to protect best practices in trademark registration, in a manner consistent with the CNIPA, which has continued to vigorously combat malicious trademark registration in recent years.
Author: Dan Liu
In a recent judgment handed down in Case T-355/21, the General Court of the EU upheld the refusal of the figurative trademark “Polo Club Düsseldorf Est. 1976” for goods in Classes 18 and 25 on the grounds that it was incompatible with the earlier Spanish trademark “POLO CLUB” (fig) for the same goods. In the judgment, the General Court provides an interesting overview of the legal criteria for comparing trademarks, on the basis of which it upholds the EUIPO’s conclusion that the new trademark gave rise to a likelihood of confusion with the prior trademark among Spanish consumers.
In its appeal against the EUIPO’s decisions, the appellant argued, in essence, that there is no likelihood of confusion between the conflicting trademarks because, on the one hand, those trademarks have a low degree of overall similarity and, on the other hand, the earlier trademark POLO CLUB (fig) lacks distinctiveness or has only weak distinctiveness. The EUIPO found that the goods at issue were identical or very similar. The parties do not dispute this finding; therefore, the focus of the debate centers on the comparison of the trademarks from the perspective of the Spanish consumer.
Decision of the General Court
In response to the plaintiff’s arguments, the General Court notes that assessing the similarity between two trademarks involves more than simply taking a single component of a composite trademark and comparing it with another trademark. Rather, the comparison must be made by examining each of the marks at issue as a whole, which does not mean that the overall impression produced on the relevant public by a composite mark cannot, in certain circumstances, be dominated by one or more of its components.
In the present case, the terms “polo club” are both dominant and the most distinctive elements of each of the marks at issue. These words, “polo club,” are more distinctive than the figurative elements that make up the marks at issue. Furthermore, the only word elements of the earlier trademark are fully included in the trademark applied for, while the other word elements comprising it—namely, the words “Düsseldorf” and “est. 1976”—are considered secondary.
In conclusion, the Court of First Instance finds that the marks at issue exhibit, from a visual standpoint, at least a low degree of similarity; from a phonetic standpoint, at least a moderate degree of similarity; and from a conceptual standpoint, a high degree of similarity. In those circumstances, as the Board of Appeal correctly noted, the similarities between the marks at issue—in particular, from a phonetic and conceptual standpoint—cannot be offset by the existence of visual differences. For all those reasons, the Board of Appeal correctly found that there was a likelihood of confusion within the meaning of Article 8(1)(b) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation.
Comment
From my perspective as a Spanish consumer, I believe that the Court’s conclusion—and, prior to that, the EUIPO’s—is correct. However, it would have been interesting to see the Court’s assessment had the relevant public been, for example, British consumers prior to Brexit.
On another note, this case illustrates the multitude of factors, circumstances, and even sensitivities that influence the conclusion regarding the possible existence of a likelihood of confusion between trademarks, and it may lead us to consider whether it would be possible for cases of this kind to be resolved exclusively using artificial intelligence-based tools in the not-too-distant future.
Author: José Ignacio San Martín
This article first appeared in WTR Daily, part of World Trademark Review, in June 2022. For more information, visit: www.worldtrademarkreview.com.
On March 12, 2022, in Case T-315/21, the General Court dismissed the action brought by the Spanish pharmaceutical company Laboratorios ERN, owner of the APIRETAL trademark, challenging the rejection of its opposition to the APIAL trademark application filed by the German company Nordesta GmbH for goods in Classes 3, 4, and 5.
Background
The opposition was based on two grounds:
The EUIPO Opposition Division dismissed the opposition on the grounds that:
At this stage, the effective use of the earlier trademark for “antipyretic pharmaceutical products” had been established.
On appeal, the EUIPO Board of Appeal confirmed that there was no similarity between the goods in Classes 3 and 4. However, it found a low degree of similarity between the goods covered by the application in Class 5 (“pharmaceutical products for skin care; nutritional supplements”) and the opponent’s goods (“antipyretic pharmaceutical products”). The opponent’s argument that the latter are a subcategory of the more general “pharmaceutical products” was rejected.
The appeal before the General Court sought to refute the Board of Appeal’s findings to the extent that the opponent contended that there was a likelihood of confusion and that the reputation of the earlier trademark had been established.
Risk of confusion
After conducting a thorough comparison of the goods, the Board of Appeals concluded that there was no similarity between the goods protected by the earlier trademark and those claimed in classes 3 and 4; they did not have the same intended use or nature and were not complementary, even though some of them shared the same distribution channels.
With regard to the goods in Class 5, it concluded that they had a low degree of similarity, since they were used differently and are neither complementary nor in competition with one another. It should be noted that consumers will pay closer attention to this type of product, especially prescription products or those requiring the involvement of a medical professional.
Both trademarks shared phonetic and visual elements, identical syllables, and identical beginnings and endings. Despite these similarities, the Board of Appeal found that the difference of three letters and the difference in length resulted in a low degree of similarity. The General Court agreed.
APIRETAL's Brand Reputation
The Court dismissed as inadmissible a market study and an affidavit from the CEO that predated the filing of the appeal before the General Court. This dismissal was based on Article 188 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court, which does not permit the subject matter of the dispute to be altered by new evidence.
With regard to the evidence submitted to demonstrate APIRETAL’s reputation—which was rejected by the Board of Appeal—the court ruled that the market studies and certificates dating from 2010, as well as a decision by the trademark office recognizing the mark’s reputation dating from 2015, had no probative value. The relevant date for establishing reputation was September 20, 2018.
Comments
Several important conclusions can be drawn from the General Court’s judgment regarding various aspects of the opposition:
This article was originally published in World Trademark Review (WTR) in English on March 28, 2022.
On April 4, 2022, the Chilean government deposited its instrument of accession to the Madrid Protocol, which allows trademark owners to opt for international trademark registration to internationalize their rights.
Chile, one of the continent’s most economically and politically stable and robust countries—vast and rich in natural resources—is now opening the door for its rights holders to take advantage of the procedures administered by WIPO.
The country has a strong capacity for exploiting raw materials, notably in the areas of fishing, mining and metals—especially copper—as well as agriculture and livestock. However, among the sectors that account for the bulk of imports from abroad are petroleum and its derivatives, industrial machinery, and vehicles—not to mention “tourists”—many of whom are European—who visit this vast and rich country each year to experience its natural diversity. It is an attractive destination for foreign investment, particularly from the United States and Europe.
With Chile's accession to the Madrid System, which will take effect on July 4, 2022, it will be possible to include this country among the more than 128 countries already participating in the system.
It seems certain that the future will involve a significant expansion of trademark rights through the Madrid System, which will allow for the inclusion of an ever-increasing number of Contracting Parties. This will undoubtedly streamline the more bureaucratic administrative procedures, while at the same time making trademark management more sophisticated. However, just because a streamlined system is used for certain procedures and parts of the process does not mean that compliance with all the legal requirements of local agencies and laws can be neglected.
Long awaited, China's accession to the Hague Agreement on the Protection of International Designs finally took place on February 5, 2022, meaning that the 1999 Act will enter into force in that country on May 5, 2022.
China's accession makes the Hague System more attractive to applicants seeking protection in numerous countries. The total number of member states in the system currently stands at 94, including the world's major markets.
Therefore, as of May 5, 2022, it will also be possible to obtain design protection in China through an international application for an industrial design under the Hague System. Applicants from China will find it easier to extend their designs beyond their own territory, and, at the same time, applicants from other countries will be able to more easily extend their designs to the Chinese market, one of the largest in the world in nearly every sector.
This provision does not apply to Hong Kong and Macao, where it will still be necessary to apply for design protection locally.
China's accession adds to the key benefits of the international registration, which are as follows:
Author: Pedro Saturio
In recent years, the number of countries that have joined the Madrid System has skyrocketed. Particularly noteworthy is the pace at which the Americas are adding members to the Protocol, which is creating new opportunities for the protection of trademarks for owners with interests in the Western Hemisphere.
Jamaica is the latest country to announce its accession to the Madrid Protocol, which is scheduled to enter into force on March 27, 2022.

The influence of North America (primarily the U.S. and Canada) on trade relations is particularly strong in this country. And although Jamaica is not a major brand-name market internationally—nor can one expect high consumption of foreign goods—it is undoubtedly an important international tourist destination where Spanish hotels have a significant presence. It is also a major producer and exporter of sugarcane, spices, and fruits; coffee; tobacco; and cannabis (a rapidly expanding market in the pharmaceutical and therapeutic industries); and, of course, reggae music, for which it is the birthplace, mecca, and universal benchmark.
Author: Cristina Arroyo
Since 2019, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has required the involvement of a local attorney in the handling of trademark applications and the provision of the owner’s email address as a prerequisite for filing trademarks with the Office. Furthermore, the Office has reserved the right to randomly request additional evidence of use of registered trademarks.
In this regard, the next step will take place on December 27, 2021, when the“Trademark Modernization Act (TMA),” enacted a year ago, takes effect. This will likely be one of the most significant milestones in recent years in U.S. trademark practice.
The TMA amends the Act in two main ways: it introduces new procedures that simplify the cancellation of trademarks that are not being used properly, and it modifies certain aspects of existing procedures.
With regard to the procedures created“ex novo,”in this article we will focus on the two most important ones, as they may alter the Office’s current landscape by seeking, in the words of our American colleagues, a “cleaning up of the register”: “Ex Parte Expungement and Reexamination Proceedings.”
The purpose of both is to ensure the proper functioning of the Office: “to make room and create space” for the registration of trademarks by owners who legitimately use their trademarks, and to prevent the registration of trademarks that are not used or are used inappropriately.
Both procedures offer a faster, easier, and less expensive alternative to the judicial process—which is exorbitantly costly in the U.S.—for canceling trademarks. And that is why, in a jurisdiction with a long history and culture of trademark protection, we may see new trends emerge in trademark protection strategies.
It is important to remember that the U.S. trademark system is based on the“first-to-use”principle and that, depending on the basis claimed in the trademark application, proof of use will be required either before or after the filing date. Therefore, the relevant time period for these purposes will depend on the claim regarding use made in each particular case.
There is no doubt that trademark protection in the U.S. will require owners to make a greater effort in selecting their protection strategies, to have an extremely realistic and accurate understanding of how they intend to use their trademarks, to provide highly precise descriptions of goods and services, and to present solid and sufficient evidence.
Consequently, as of December 27, 2021, trademark owners will not only have to pass the screening of their affidavits of use, but there will also be a risk of trademark cancellation at the request of third parties or the Office itself.
The TMA also clarifies certain aspects of existing procedures:
Thus, in trademark cancellation proceedings before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB), the fact that a registered trademark has never been used in commerce is added as a ground for cancellation. This ground may be invoked after the first three years from the date of registration.
Although it will not take effect until January 1, 2022, the flexibility and shorter timeframes provided for in the TMA are particularly relevant when resolving official actions identified by the Office. The deadlines for responding to an official action will be three months, rather than the generous six months currently allowed.
Finally, we also believe it is worth noting the introduction of a two-month deadline for third parties to file what is known in the U.S. as a “Letter of Protest” (a type of statement or request for evidence) regarding a ground for refusal of trademark registration during examination proceedings.
These are undoubtedly significant changes intended to ensure that the trademark registration process and the smooth functioning of the U.S. market are not undermined; in some cases, they will affect the strategies designed by trademark owners to defend, protect, and maintain their trademarks in a jurisdiction that is essential to the portfolios of trademark owners worldwide.
Author: Cristina Arroyo
The United Arab Emirates has signed the instrument of accession to the Madrid Protocol, which will enter into force on December 28, 2021. With the addition of this country, there are now 125 members of the Madrid System, three of which are members of the Cooperation Council for the Arab States of the Gulf. Oman and Bahrain were already members of the system.

This Persian Gulf country is one of the richest countries in the world and ranks among the top five in terms of per capita income. Wealth is concentrated primarily in the two largest emirates, Dubai (the most cosmopolitan) and Abu Dhabi (the most conservative and the country’s capital), and is based mainly on oil and natural gas production, although tourism, the financial and real estate sectors, and construction have become increasingly important in recent years. It plays a key and strategic role in Middle Eastern and global diplomacy and is one of the main gateways to Asia.
Its stability and wealth make it attractive to foreign investment and international trade, with the luxury market proving to be particularly significant.
One of the obstacles posed by the domestic route for trademark protection in the United Arab Emirates is the high cost of local legal services and official fees, which are extremely high in some cases. The fee for international applications in the United Arab Emirates is still unknown, and it is almost certain that the country has reserved the right to charge a separate fee; however, joining the international system will likely offer trademark owners a cost advantage when protecting their trademarks.
Author: Cristina Arroyo