Traces of movement: exclusion from the registry based on technical function according to the TG

Case Background and Trademark Application

On July 26, 2023, the German company KCT GMBH & CO KG filed an application to register the trademark shown below to distinguish a specific type of window; the trademark was classified asa motion mark.

The following clarification was included in the trademark description:“When opened, the window sash moves downward and outward relative to the fixed frame. The window sash slides downward along the fixed frame. In addition, a black spacer is visible on both sides of the movable window frame.”

The trademark application was rejected. The subsequent appeal was dismissed by a decision dated October 28, 2024 (R 740/2024-2). The Board of Appeal found that the trademark in question consisted exclusively of a specific feature necessary to achieve the technical result intended by the product in question; that is, to allow light and air to enter an enclosed space by opening and closing the window [Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of the EUTMR 2017/1001]. It also found that the mark lacked distinctiveness [Article 7(1)(b) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation 2017/1001].

The General Court of the European Union (hereinafter “GC”), by judgment of January 14, 2026 (T-9/25) dismisses the action and confirms that the trademark applied for falls under Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of the EU Trademark Regulation 2017/1001 (technical effect), without addressing the issue of lack of distinctiveness.

The essential characteristics of the mark, as described by KCT in its arguments, are as follows: a) the movement of the inner rectangular white frame within the outer rectangular frame; b) the appearance and disappearance of the black dividers between the frames during that movement; c) the change in color at the top and bottom of the inner frame during that movement.

In KCT’s view, the characteristics of the mark, once examined and analyzed individually and collectively, lead to the conclusion that the “moving window” does not consist exclusively of a shape or other specific feature of the product intended to achieve a technical result. Furthermore, it is argued that the movement itself differs from what is commonly known in the industry and that there are other alternatives for achieving the result; it is also argued that the color change that occurs is decorative and, as such, constitutes an essential element.

Applicable Legal Framework

The General Court begins by setting forth the principles underlying the prohibition in Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001, based on the consideration that its purpose is to prevent the use of a trademark to monopolize technical solutions or functional characteristics of a product that would be protected by other forms of industrial property with limited-term protection (judgment of September 18, 2014, Hauck, C-205/13, EU:C:2014:2233, paragraph 19).

The first step in assessing the prohibition set forth in Article 7.1(2)(ii) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation 201771001 may, depending on the sign in question, be based on the overall impression that the sign creates visually or on the identification of its essential characteristics (Judgment of April 23, 2020, Gömböc, C-237/19, EU:C:2020:296, para. 29).

Once this preliminary examination has been conducted, it must be determined whether all the features are essential to fulfilling a technical function, since this prohibition does not apply if a non-functional element—such as an ornamental or fanciful element—plays an important role (judgment of September 14, 2010, Lego Juris v. OHIM, C-48/09 P, EU:C:2010:516, paragraph 72).

Finally, the analysis of technical features must be based on objective and reliable information, such as that contained in the trademark registration application or other data derived from the existence of other industrial property rights, research, expert opinions, scientific publications, etc. (Judgment of April 23, 2020, Gömböc, C-237/19, EU:C:2020:296, paragraph 34).

Assessment by the General Court

The General Court confirms that the mark contains essential characteristics that serve a technical function. The fundamental characteristic of the mark is a sequence of movements consisting of opening and closing a window. This movement involves the opening and closing mechanisms attached to the inner frame, which do not play an independent role in relation to the sequence of movements necessary to achieve the intended technical result.

The function of the spacers is purely technical, as they are an important component that helps stabilize and reinforce the window and support the window sash as it moves forward.

The TG’s first conclusion is that all the essential characteristics of the trademark applied for—that is, the opening and closing motion of the window, including the movement of the dividers—are necessary to achieve the technical result of the product that the trademark is intended to distinguish; therefore, it falls under Article 7.1(e)(ii) of the EUTM Regulation 2017/1001.

The sign incorporates other elements that the TG does not consider essential, such as the color change that occurs when the window is opened or closed—which can only be perceived as a shadow that appears and disappears as the window opens and closes. This change represents merely the normal interplay of light and shadow on a moving three-dimensional object and is not particularly striking; it is considered minor. This characteristic serves to refute another argument based on the possible ornamental nature of this aspect, which would have no bearing on the matter since it is not relevant.

Interestingly, the “Common Practice on New Types of Trademarks: Examination of Formal Requirements and Grounds for Refusal” (CP11) acknowledges that motion trademarks are not limited to signs that depict movement, but may also consist of elements that show a change in the position of the elements, such as a change in color. However, the TG clarifies that the assessment must be made on a case-by-case basis, and the fact that, a priori, a change in color may constitute an essential element of a motion mark does not mean that, in all cases, such a change constitutes an essential element—which is precisely what occurs in the case at hand.

Likewise, the argument that there are alternative technical solutions for opening and closing windows—which is the functionality of the disputed mark—is also unacceptable. As stated above, the fact that such alternatives exist does not mean that the prohibition does not apply, since their existence does not imply that other operators may use the technical solution embodied in the disputed mark.

Indeed, if a trademark with such a characteristic is granted, even if alternatives exist, competitors could be prohibited from using goods with an identical or similar characteristic [judgments of September 14, 2010, Lego Juris v. OHIM, C-48/09 P, EU:C:2010:516, paragraphs 53–56, and of January 31, 2018, Novartis v. EUIPO – SK Chemicals (Representation of a transdermal patch), T-44/16, EU:T:2018:48, paragraph 56].

Therefore, based on all these criteria, the General Court concludes that the trademark in question infringes Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of the EU Trademark Regulation 2017/1001, without assessing its distinctiveness. To that end, it reiterates the principle that, in order to refuse a European Union trademark, it is sufficient that it infringes any one of the prohibitions set forth in Article 7(1) of the EU Trademark Regulation 2017/1001.

Furthermore, it should be noted that an appeal may be filed with the Court of Justice against this judgment within two months of the date of its notification.

Jesús Gómez Montero

Former Partner ELZABURU

IP Academic Advisor (Trademarks)

The Invalidity of the European Collective Mark “Jabugo”

The recent decision by the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) to declare the European Union collective trademark “JABUGO”—owned by the Asociación Auténtico Jabugo—null and void, at the request of the Regulatory Council of the Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) “Jabugo,” has reignited the debate over the boundaries between trademark law and geographical indications.

The ruling provides a significant opportunity to analyze how the distinctiveness requirements are applied in the context of collective trademarks, particularly when such trademarks incorporate geographic names that are widely recognized by the public.

Why the EUIPO Considers That “Jabugo” Cannot Be a Valid Collective Mark

Article 7(1)(c) of the European Union Trademark Regulation (EUTMR) prohibits the registration of trademarks consisting exclusively of signs or indications that may serve, in trade, to designate, among other things, the geographical origin of the goods or services.

However, in the specific context of collective marks, Article 74(2) of the EUTM Regulation establishes an exception: signs that may serve to indicate the geographical origin of goods may constitute collective marks. This provision is known as the geographical exception.

However, this exception does not exempt collective marks from compliance with the other absolute grounds for refusal set forth in Article 7(1) of the EUTM Regulation. Therefore, the exception under Article 74(2) of the EUTM Regulation applies only to those collective marks that are distinctive.

In the decision under review, the Cancellation Division concludes that, as of the filing date of the contested trademark, the term “Jabugo” was recognized as a municipality in the province of Huelva where high-quality hams and related products are produced. Consequently, Spanish consumers will perceive the sign as a direct reference to the geographic origin of the products for which the collective mark was registered, and the mark is declared invalid for lacking sufficient distinctiveness.

What does it mean for “Jabugo” to be considered a descriptive term?

The Cancellation Division concludes that the contested trademark, although descriptive of the geographical origin of the goods, could be covered by the exception set forth in Article 74(2) of the EUTMR. However, that geographical exception does not exempt it from meeting the distinctiveness requirement set forth in Article 7(1)(b) of the EUTMR with respect to all the contested goods.

The direct consequence of this finding is that the Auténtico Jabugo Association cannot claim exclusive rights to the term “JABUGO” under European Union trademark law.

What evidence was required to prove distinctiveness acquired through use?

To establish that the term “Jabugo” had acquired distinctive character through use, the Asociación Auténtico Jabugo should have demonstrated that the relevant public in the European Union perceives the term “Jabugo” as an indicator of the collective commercial origin associated with its members.

This type of accreditation requires solid evidence, including, but not limited to:

  • Perception surveys conducted in several Member States.
  • Extensive and detailed data on sales, advertising, and commercial presence that demonstrate the use of the term as a trademark.
  • Information regarding the brand's market share.
  • Evidence regarding the intensity, geographic scope, and duration of the sign's use.
  • Evidence of the proportion of the relevant public that identifies the products as coming from a specific company based on the brand.

The ruling notes that the statements provided by the Chambers of Commerce refer to the terms “name,” “reference,” or “product” when mentioning “Jamón de Jabugo,” but do not establish that “Jabugo,” on its own, is perceived as a trademark that identifies the hams produced by the members of the association in question.

Practical Consequences of the Nullification for the Auténtico Jabugo Association and the Industry

The immediate consequence of the declaration of invalidity is that the Auténtico Jabugo Association cannot claim exclusive rights to or monopolize the term “JABUGO” through a collective trademark.

Furthermore, only ham producers who meet the requirements established by the “Jabugo” Protected Designation of Origin may use that term. Consequently, companies that belong to the Auténtico Jabugo Association but do not meet the PDO requirements may not use the term “JABUGO” to refer to their products.

Relationship Between the Canceled Trademark and the “Jabugo” PDO

In practice, the invalidated collective trademark and the PDO will not coexist. With the trademark registration now void, the legitimate use of the term “Jabugo” is exclusively tied to compliance with the requirements of the Protected Designation of Origin.

Thus, if any of the companies belonging to the Auténtico Jabugo Association fails to meet the PDO requirements, it will not be allowed to use the term “JABUGO” to refer to hams.

Future Scenarios: Resources, New Entries, and Control Over the Use of the Term

The decision of the Cancellation Division may be appealed to the Board of Appeal of the EUIPO until January 19, 2026. If the appeal is denied, a further appeal may be filed with the General Court of the European Union.

A new EU trademark application consisting of the term “JABUGO” and covering “hams” would be opposed on the same grounds on which the “JABUGO” registration was canceled (lack of distinctiveness). Article 7(1)(j) of the EU Trademark Regulation might also apply, under which the registration of trademarks that include designations of origin will be refused provided that certain conditions are met.

Once the decision becomes final, the next step for the Regulatory Council will be to ensure that all uses of the term “JABUGO” comply with the PDO, since members of the Auténtico Jabugo Association who do not meet its requirements will not be able to rely on the collective mark to use that term.

Elzaburu has extensive experience in industrial and intellectual property, advising companies and associations on the registration, protection, and defense of trademarks, designations of origin, and other intangible assets, with a rigorous and up-to-date approach to the law.

Marta Rodríguez, Senior Associate in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu.

What the “No Ni Ná” Case Has Taught Us: The Value of Originality in Brand Building

In an increasingly competitive market, where brands seek not only to capture consumers' attention but also to stand out in saturated environments, creativity and originality have become essential strategic elements.

A recent example that illustrates this scenario is the dispute over the “No Ni Ná” trademark, launched by Paz Padilla and her daughter for a fashion line. In this case, the replacement of the letter “I” with a fishbone has raised legal questions that go beyond the design itself: Can a common symbol acquire distinctiveness? What conditions must a trademark meet to be successfully registered?

What does it mean for a trademark to be distinctive?

Distinctiveness is what makes a brand unique and allows consumers to associate a product or service with the company that offers it. When a sign fails to establish that connection, it ceases to fulfill its essential purpose.

Trademark registration authorities evaluate this distinctiveness by considering two key factors:

  1. The products or services you wish to protect.
  2. The perception of the target audience the brand is aimed at.

If a trademark lacks distinctiveness, it cannot be registered. Among the most common reasons are:

  • Descriptiveness: This occurs when the mark directly describes characteristics of the product or service, such as its nature, quality, or origin. Example: using “DULCE” for confectionery products.
  • Use of generic terms: words commonly used in an industry, such as “SOFTWARE” for computer programs.
  • Common expressions in commerce: terms that have become part of everyday language, such as “BIO” for organic foods.
  • Overly generic slogans: Phrases like “THE BEST FOR YOU” do not allow consumers to identify a specific company.
  • Functional shapes or those dictated by the nature of the product: In the case of three-dimensional trademarks, shapes that are essential or commonplace—such as the basic outline of a bottle—cannot be registered.
  • Designs that are too generic or common: overly simple elements, such as a red circle for electronic products, do not allow one company to stand out from another.

Identifying symbols as a distinguishing feature: an increasingly demanding landscape

Not all components of a trademark need to be equally distinctive. A trademark may include elements that, taken individually, have weak distinctiveness or lack distinctiveness entirely.

The use of recognizable icons as trademarks is common in industries such as fashion. Examples such as the skull used by SCALPERS FASHION S.L. or the puma used by Puma SE demonstrate that symbols can become highly distinctive.

But that popularity has led to stricter registration criteria. In the case of “No Ni Ná, ” fish bones are commonly used as a reference to Cádiz and areas such as Zahara de los Atunes, which makes it difficult to consider it an exclusive mark.

To defend its registration, the company would have to prove that:

  • Consumers do not associate the "raspa" with a generic symbol of the industry.
  • Or that, after prolonged and continuous use, the design has acquired a high degree of distinctiveness or even renown, as is the case with Longchamp’s horseman on horseback, which is unmistakably recognized by the public.

Copyright Protection: An Important Limit

Just because a sign lacks distinctiveness does not mean it is without legal protection. If the design of the “No Ni Ná” logo is original and unique, it could be protected by copyright.

However, this protection would only prevent the exact copying of the specific design, not the use of generic variations of the motif. Therefore, a lawsuit against a different fish scale design would have little chance of success.

Tips for Creating Original Brands and Avoiding Conflicts

The “No Ni Ná” case demonstrates the importance of investing in distinctive and creative branding from the very beginning. Here are some key recommendations for entrepreneurs and designers:

  1. Avoid generic or common terms used in the industry.
  2. Opt for invented, arbitrary, or evocative symbols that have no direct connection to the product or service. Some successful examples include Google and Apple in the technology sector.
  3. Conduct a preliminary trademark search to avoid conflicts.
  4. Seek advice from a professional specializing in intellectual property before launching the brand on the market.

Originality as a Brand Positioning Strategy

The level of distinctiveness required may vary by industry. In highly saturated sectors such as fashion, cosmetics, or food, finding truly distinctive marks is more challenging. Conversely, in technology or emerging sectors, where there is greater creative freedom, it is easier to meet this requirement.

In any case, the more unique, original, and memorable the trademark is, the greater the chances of successfully registering it and establishing it in the market.

Lorena Sánchez, Attorneys and Specialists in the Trademark Department at Elzaburu

1865: A year marked by Elzaburu and major advances that laid the foundation for the modern world

In 1865, significant advances were made in various fields of knowledge and technology. Some of these went unnoticed at the time, while others marked the beginning of business ventures that are now global leaders. Elzaburu was founded that same year, at a time when science, industry, and culture were beginning to organize themselves around the protection of innovation.

In this article, we highlight ten milestones that occurred in the same year our firm was founded and that have played a significant role in shaping what we now understand as industrial and intellectual property.

  1. Mendel's Laws: Genetics Ahead of Its Time

In 1865, Gregor Mendel presented his studies on genetic inheritance. Although his conclusions were not recognized until decades later, his experiments laid the foundation for modern biotechnology, a field that today generates thousands of patents each year. They serve as a clear example of how scientific knowledge takes time to be valued and protected.

  1. Joseph Lister and Surgical Antisepsis

That same year, British surgeon Joseph Lister began using carbolic acid (phenol) to sterilize instruments. His technique reduced postoperative infections and transformed medicine, paving the way for the protection of medical and pharmaceutical innovations. Antisepsis marked the beginning of a new era in surgery, and its application led to patentable developments in the hospital setting.

  1. Maxwell's Equations: Applied Science

In 1865, James Clerk Maxwell formulated the equations that unified electricity, magnetism, and light. This theoretical breakthrough led to technologies such as radio, television, and telecommunications, all of which are protected by intellectual property rights. Fundamental physics, in this case, became the foundation for numerous industrial sectors that continue to evolve today.

  1. Alfred Nobel and Nitroglycerin

In Sweden, Alfred Nobel founded his first nitroglycerin factory. Two years later, he would invent dynamite. His career illustrates how a scientific discovery can become a protected and commercially viable innovation. Furthermore, his legacy was cemented in the field of intellectual property with the creation of the Nobel Prizes, which recognize scientific and literary excellence.

  1. The Elevator and Vertical Architecture

In 1865, the installation of elevators in office buildings began to become widespread, following the development of the safety brake by Elisha Otis. This technology transformed urban design and enabled the vertical growth of cities. Its technical evolution has been accompanied by numerous engineering developments that have been subject to industrial protection.

  1. The Railroad as a Driver of Patents

That same year, the railroad network continued to expand in both Europe and the Americas. In Spain, connections between Madrid and cities such as Barcelona, Valencia, Seville, and Lisbon were being consolidated. This infrastructure, which transformed mobility and trade, relied on thousands of technical innovations protected by patents: from locomotives to signaling systems and track materials. The railroad is a clear example of how industrial property has been a driving force for progress in strategic sectors.

  1. The Origins of Nestlé

In 1865, Henri Nestlé developed a formula for infant nutrition that led to the founding of the Nestlé company. Today, the company is a global leader in brand management, with a solid strategy for protecting its corporate identity. Its evolution demonstrates how a well-established brand can remain relevant for more than a century and a half.

  1. Alice in Wonderland

That year, Lewis Carroll published *Alice in Wonderland*, a work that became a classic of children’s literature. Its success demonstrates the value of copyright in the dissemination and protection of creative works. Intellectual property rights have made it possible for this work to be adapted, translated, and marketed in multiple formats and territories.

  1. The Transatlantic Telegraph Cable

In 1865, the first telegraph cable between Ireland and Newfoundland was successfully laid. This technical feat revolutionized communications and led to patents in telegraphy, marking the beginning of global connectivity. The transmission of real-time messages between continents was the seed from which the networks that underpin today’s digital economy grew.

  1. The Bessemer Process and Modern Steel

The Bessemer process became established in 1865, enabling the mass and efficient production of steel. This innovation was protected by patents and became the foundation for major infrastructure projects and industrial developments. Steel facilitated the construction of bridges, trains, factories, and buildings, and remains a key material in contemporary engineering.

Elzaburu: a company born out of the same innovative environment

As these advances were taking place, Elzaburu was founded. Since then, we have worked alongside inventors, authors, and companies to protect their creations. Sharing our founding year with so many significant milestones reinforces our commitment to protecting the things that transform the world. Industrial and intellectual property not only preserves the value of ideas but also drives their development and application.

Elisa Prieto, Head of Knowledge Management at Elzaburu

Trademark Protection Strategies in the Music Industry: The Case of Rosalía’s “LUX” Trademark

Registering a trademark associated with a musical project has become an essential tool in the industrial property and intellectual property strategies of contemporary artists. Rosalía’s recent application for the European trademark “LUX,” months before the release of her new album, illustrates how trademark law can anticipate market trends and protect the commercial value of the intangible assets associated with artistic creation.

Early Registration and Legal Priority

Filing an application for a European Union trademark before the launch of a cultural or musical product allows the applicant to establish a priority date and obtain a presumption of legal protection against third parties. In the case of “LUX,” the artist filed the application on June 6, 2025, for classes 9, 25, and 41, which include musical recordings, clothing, and entertainment services.

This strategy prevents potential opportunistic registrations by third parties seeking to profit from the commercial value of the mark and facilitates the drafting of licensing agreements ( merchandising, distribution, etc.) with greater legal certainty.

The application is currently under review by the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO). Once this stage is complete, a three-month period will begin during which holders of prior rights may file an opposition on relative grounds. Consequently, an opposition could still be filed if there are similar prior trademarks.

Risks of Not Registering a Trademark in Other Jurisdictions

One of the fundamental principles of trademark law is its territorial nature. This means that the protection granted by a European Union trademark is effective only within that territory.

Failure to register the trademark in relevant jurisdictions may leave the owner vulnerable to unauthorized use or prior registrations by third parties. In this case, Rosalía has also applied for registration in the United Kingdom and the United States, a move consistent with the international significance of her previous Motomami World Tour.

However, at this time, there is no record of an application in China, where releasing the album before registration could have made it easier for a third party to beat them to it. Without a local registration, it would be more difficult to take action against potential infringements or misuse of the “LUX” mark in that market.

The Distinctive Character of “LUX”

One of the key factors in granting a trademark is its distinctiveness. The EUIPO examines applications to rule out generic or descriptive signs in accordance with the absolute grounds for refusal set forth in the EU Trademark Regulation.

Although “LUX” means “light” in Latin and is commonly associated with luxury, this term does not directly describe the protected goods or services (such as clothing, musical recordings, or entertainment services). Therefore, there are no apparent legal obstacles to its registration.

Figurative and Symbolic Trademarks: Specific Characteristics

At the same time, another trademark related to “LUX” is a symbol. These figurative trademarks may also be registered, provided they are not limited to generic shapes and possess sufficient distinctiveness.

Unlike word marks, their distinctiveness is assessed from a visual perspective, based on whether the graphic symbol allows the business or artistic origin of the goods and services offered to be identified.

Disclosure and Transparency in Applications

In the case of European Union trademark applications, it is common for the timeline and information regarding potential oppositions not to be displayed until the application is published. This is because, while the application is under examination, the opposition period has not yet begun, and certain information is accessible only to the owner or the owner’s authorized representative before the Office.

The European Union Intellectual Property Office does not provide for the confidential processing of applications; therefore, this would not constitute a confidentiality strategy. Once the application is published, all essential information would become public.

Trademark Ownership and Relationship with the Record Label

In this case, for the record label to be able to claim a share of the revenue derived from the use of the trademarks, we must rely on what was agreed upon between the parties. In principle, without a formal licensing agreement with the record label, the artist herself will receive the revenue generated by the use of the trademarks registered in her name.

Legal Strategies for Capitalizing on Intangible Assets

When it comes to developing a strategy to capitalize on an album release, various factors come into play, depending on the creativity of the artist or the team. An example of how to leverage intangible assets in this context is the case of Rosalía’s album cover, unveiled at a massive event in Callao. To create the cover, certain rights must be assigned by the collaborators involved—such as the photographer or designer—and these rights are typically owned by the record label, in this case, Columbia Records.

Another way to capitalize on a release—by leveraging intangible assets—is through “listening parties,” a format that originated in the United States and has been used by major artists such as Ye (a.k.a. Kanye West). These types of events serve not only as a promotional tool to generate buzz but also as a unique experience for fans, who can listen to the album for the first time alongside the artist. Rosalía, in particular, has opted for a more intimate format than other artists, thereby creating a more personal connection with her audience and enhancing the experience surrounding the release. This has undoubtedly made it necessary to consider a series of legal measures to protect such activities. For example, formalizing contracts with venues, obtaining public communication licenses, establishing data processing conditions, and managing access. In short, as with almost all music releases, it is the combination of legal measures that makes the difference in determining whether a product will be successful.

Common Mistakes in Intangible Asset Management

The first step in capitalizing on intangible assets to avoid future problems with an album release is to ensure that you have all the necessary rights assignments or licenses for phonographic and publishing exploitation, as well as trademark registrations and rights to other key elements such as artwork, cover designs, and any visual material associated with the release. It is essential to avoid any type of claim for rights infringement, both during the release phase and after the product has been distributed.

A common—and potentially costly—mistake is failing to formalize agreements with producers, performers, and collaborators. It is not uncommon, even today, to see albums released in both physical and digital formats that later lead to claims of copyright or moral rights infringement. These disputes can arise for reasons such as the unauthorized use of samples or rights assignments that were not properly signed. In addition, visual elements—such as the cover art or any other graphic material used in promotion—must be adequately protected to avoid conflicts related to intellectual property.

Lucía Palomino, Attorney in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu, & Jesús Nogués, Attorney in the Media and Entertainment practice group at Elzaburu.

Image: Rosalía's website and EUIPO.

The EUIPO has refused the “TEQUIFRESA” trademark on the grounds that it evokes the geographical indication “Tequila”

The European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) recently rejected the application to register the trademark TEQUIFRESA for alcoholic beverages in Class 33. The decision is based on the fact that the sign applied for evokes the geographical indication (GI) “Tequila,” which is protected by both European regulations and international agreements with Mexico.

This case is a good example of how European regulations protect geographical indications against attempts to register trademarks that might take unfair advantage of their reputation or mislead consumers.

Background of the Case

The applicant, Fraternity Spirits World Inc., filed an application for the word mark TEQUIFRESA in Class 33 to designate: “Alcoholic beverages, except beers.”

In its initial communication dated May 27, 2025, the EUIPO raised an objection pursuant to Article 7(1)(j) of the European Union Trademark Regulation (EUTMR), finding that the trademark evoked the geographical indication (GI) “Tequila.”

The applicant did not file any arguments within the allotted time limit; therefore, the Office upheld the rejection in its decision of August 22, 2025.

Legal Rationale of the EUIPO

Strengthened Protection of the “Tequila” Geographical Indication (GI)

In its decision denying the application, the EUIPO noted that the term “Tequila” enjoys dual protection:

  1. Pursuant to Regulation (EC) No. 2024/1143 of April 11, 2024, which regulates geographical indications for spirits in the European Union.
  2. Pursuant to the Agreement between the European Community and the United Mexican States on the Mutual Recognition and Protection of Designations in the Spirits Sector (OJEU L 152, June 11, 1997).

Definition of the term “protected”

The EUIPO determined that the trademark application for “TEQUIFRESA” includes the element “TEQUI,” which evokes the term “Tequila.” The addition of the term “FRESA” would not eliminate that association.

Furthermore, with regard to the goods applied for in Class 33 (“Alcoholic beverages, except beers”), the EUIPO considers that this description includes“agave-based spirits,” which do not have the origin indicated by the geographical indication referred to in the trademark for which protection is sought.

Consequences of the resolution

The EUIPO, pursuant to Article 7(1)(j) of the EUTM Regulation, rejected the trademark application for TEQUIFRESA.

In accordance with Articles 67 and 68 of the RMUE, the applicant has the right to file an appeal within two months of notification and will then have an additional two months to present the arguments they deem relevant.

Significance of the Decision for Trademark Owners and Applicants

This case highlights several key aspects that trademark applicants should consider when planning their trademark strategy in the European Union.

The ruling confirms that geographical indications enjoy enhanced protection that not only prevents the registration of an identical term but also any reference—even partial—such as the inclusion of the element “TEQUI” in the trademark application, which is capable of leading consumers to associate it with the geographical indication “Tequila” even when accompanied by other elements or names.

Furthermore, this case underscores the need to conduct thorough preliminary searches not only for trademarks but also for geographical indications, thereby reinforcing the importance of developing robust trademark strategies that are aligned with current regulations.

Marta Rodríguez, Senior Associate in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu

Who Can Register an AI-Generated Trademark? The Brainrot Case and the Legal Challenges of Viral Creativity

The emergence of surreal characters generated by artificial intelligence (AI) on platforms like TikTok has sparked a viral phenomenon known as Italian Brainrot. These creations (such as Tralalero Tralala, Tung Tung Tung Sahur, and Ballerina Cappuccina) have taken the market by storm in the form of trading cards, toys, video games, and merchandise, but they have also raised important legal questions regarding their protection.

Is it possible to register a trademark without being the creator?

Under the trademark system of the European Union and Spain, the “first-to-file” rule grants exclusive rights to the first party to file an application with the competent office (EUIPO or OEPM), regardless of whether that party is the original creator (since the primary function of trademarks is to indicate the commercial origin of the product or service). This has led multiple parties to attempt to register names associated with the Brainrot universe, resulting in a flood of applications and potential conflicts.

However, the law sets clear limits: if it is shown that an application was filed in bad faith (for example, to misappropriate preexisting rights), it may be challenged. But the burden of proof always rests with the claimant.

Can authorship be protected in AI-generated works?

Current legislation recognizes copyright only for individuals. In the case of characters created using AI, the recognition of authorship depends on the degree of human intervention and the presence of originality. If the result is the product of precise instructions and creative control by the prompt writer, it could be considered a protected work, provided it possesses originality and creative merit. The challenge lies in being able to prove it.

In addition, the terms and conditions of use for AI platforms may affect ownership of the results, which adds complexity to legal protection.

Trade Frictions and Brand Coexistence

The proliferation of trademarks selling products associated with Brainrot may lead to commercial friction, with cross-oppositions between applicants. However, it may also be the case that simultaneous applications result in the peaceful coexistence of trademarks when they cover distinct market segments—provided, of course, that no legal action is taken against them by their legitimate owners.

For example, the same name could coexist if it is used for different products (such as toys versus clothing) and does not cause confusion among consumers. This possibility, although less common, is legally viable and can be a strategic option for companies that wish to capitalize on the popularity of the phenomenon without entering into direct conflict with other owners who already hold the registration. However, this does not prevent a legitimate owner who can prove their rights from challenging the registration or filing infringement claims, as appropriate.

How can you protect yourself against unauthorized copying and use?

The proliferation of products inspired by Brainrot has led to commercial friction and the risk of plagiarism. To prevent this, it is essential to have an adequate protection strategy in place: registering trademarks and designs, actively monitoring the market, and using technological tools to detect counterfeits.

Platforms such as Amazon, eBay, and Google allow for the removal of infringing products within 24–48 hours if ownership of the right is proven. However, for this protection to be effective, there must be both a valid, enforceable right and a right holder.

Are we looking at a folk creation?

The difficulty in identifying legitimate authors has led some experts to compare the phenomenon to folk creations passed down orally. If no one claims authorship of characters such as Tralalero Tralala, or of the content featuring them (videos, memes, songs), copyright protection remains open to anyone, subject to a claim by anyone who believes their legitimate rights have been infringed.

What if the Brainrot phenomenon fades away?

The regulations provide that trademarks that are not actually and effectively used for five years shall lapse. However, this period is considered a reasonable timeframe for the owner to begin commercial exploitation of the trademark. In viral phenomena such as Brainrot, this “grace period” can be decisive in establishing a monetization strategy.

The viral nature of AI-generated creations poses new challenges for trademark and intellectual property law. In this context, specialized legal advice is key to avoiding conflicts, protecting intangible assets, and capitalizing on the opportunities offered by the digital environment. At Elzaburu, we work with companies, creators, and rights holders to design effective legal strategies for registering, defending, and exploiting their trademarks in an increasingly complex and digitized ecosystem.

Enrique Jacobo, a trademark attorney at Elzaburu.

Lamine Yamal and the Strategy of Trademark Registration: Beyond Soccer

The link between sports and intellectual property continues to grow stronger. A year ago, we examined how certain soccer celebrations could be registered as distinctive marks. Today, we find a new example of this trend in Lamine Yamal, who recently registered seven European Union trademarks with the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO).

Personal Branding as a Strategic Asset

Registering trademarks with the EUIPO is no small matter: it involves establishing a legal framework to protect intangible assets that will accompany the athlete both on and off the field. In Yamal’s case, this strategy will allow him to control the use of his first and last names through two different trademark registrations, as well as the gesture he makes when scoring a goal (304) through five other registered trademarks, preventing third parties from using any of these elements as trademarks or capitalizing on them without his authorization.

Last May, the first trademarks were registered with the EUIPO for sports apparel and footwear, caps, and various types of clothing. Shortly thereafter, protection was expanded by filing applications to register the word marks “LY304,” “304,” and “304 FC” for a broader range of products, including soccer balls, gloves, action figures, sunglasses, helmets, watches, headphones, backpacks, barbells, and video games. This extension of protection reflects a strategic, long-term vision, which advises registering a trademark not only for products or services whose launch is imminent, but also for those to which the brand’s use might be extended in the medium or long term.

Gestures as Distinctive Signs

A year ago, we noted how players like Kylian Mbappé had registered their celebrations as trademarks. In Yamal’s case, the trademark protection for his goal-scoring gesture (number 304) refers to the last three digits of the ZIP code for his neighborhood, Rocafonda, in Mataró (Barcelona).

Lamine Yamal's Celebration: A Record of the Gesture He Made After Scoring a Goal

Lamine Yamal's Celebration: A Record of the Gesture He Made After Scoring a Goal

The registration of this celebration does not protect its performance on the field ( where any other player could perform it without infringing the trademark), but rather its use in the commercial sphere. In other words, it grants the owner an exclusive right to commercially exploit the gesture protected by the trademark and to prevent third parties from using it on products or services without authorization, thereby establishing it as an asset capable of commercial exploitation.

It is also worth noting that, in addition to the protection afforded by trademark law, claims based on copyright (provided sufficient originality is demonstrated) or on the protection of the right to reputation, privacy, and one’s own image may arise in some cases.

A forward-looking strategy

A soccer player’s career, no matter how successful, has a limited duration. Trademark registration is a key tool that allows an elite soccer player to extend his or her economic, social, and cultural influence beyond their time on the field. In this regard, Yamal’s decision reflects a clear understanding that his image and distinctive marks are part of an intangible asset that should be protected from the very beginning.

Furthermore, the combination of such a unique and personal way of celebrating his goals, a number that holds special significance for him, and his geographic origins also reinforces the brand’s authenticity, creating a narrative that blends personal identity, a connection to his hometown, athletic success, and public recognition.

The case of Lamine Yamal confirms an increasingly established trend: elite soccer players are adopting a strategy of protecting as trademarks not only their names and nicknames, but also their goal-celebration gestures and other personal symbols that represent their identity.

At Elzaburu, we are closely monitoring this trend, convinced that intellectual property has become a key element in managing athletes’ identities and creating value beyond the playing field.

Fernando Ilardia, Partner in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu

The Evolution of the Pharmaceutical Industry: From “Patent Medicines” to Patented Drugs

The evolution of medicinal remedies into the modern pharmaceutical industry is closely linked to the development of intellectual property, the protection of inventions, and the consolidation of regulatory systems that are now essential to public health. Throughout the 19th and 20th centuries, the concept of a medicine evolved from an advertising claim with no scientific basis into a regulated product, backed by patents, clinical evidence, and institutional oversight.

“Patent Medicines”: Brands Without Scientific Backing

During the second half of the 19th century, rapid urban growth, precarious working conditions, and poor sanitation created an environment conducive to the spread of epidemics. Against this backdrop, the public, desperate for solutions, turned to so-called “patent medicines.”

Despite their name, these products were not pharmaceutical patents in the modern sense. In reality, they were registered trademarks under which supposedly curative remedies were marketed, without undergoing any quality control or verification of efficacy. Manufacturers protected the name and the secrecy of the formula through trademark registration, which allowed them to operate indefinitely as long as they paid the corresponding fees.

Most of these formulas contained alcohol, opioids, and other ingredients of questionable safety, and they were sold over the counter—even to children, pregnant women, and the elderly. The consequences were inevitable: cases of poisoning, serious side effects, and even deaths.

In the following video, Elisa Prieto (Head of Knowledge Management at Elzaburu) summarizes how Patent Medicines came to be and why they captivated the public; their pioneering role in the widespread use of advertising; and how regulation and science put an end to these “miracles” from the apothecary.

First Steps Toward Health Care Regulation

Growing concerns about public health prompted medical associations and authorities to take action. Healthcare professionals began to reveal the true composition of these products and the risks they posed, while regulatory agencies developed regulations that required authorization procedures for the marketing of drugs.

By the 1920s, most patent medicines had disappeared, giving way to a more transparent healthcare model based on scientific research.

Consolidation of the Pharmaceutical Industry and the Patent System

The disappearance of “patent medicines” marked the beginning of a completely different era: the industrialization of medicine. For the first time, scientific research and the protection of inventions through pharmaceutical patents took center stage in production. As a result, medicines ceased to be artisanal preparations and came to be produced using standardized and controlled processes.

The ELZABURU historical archives contain significant examples of this transition:

Eno Fruit Salts

Created by James Crossley and registered in Spain in the late 19th century, they were originally developed as a multipurpose remedy. Over time, they evolved into a well-established antacid product in the GSK pharmaceutical catalog, with a global presence.

Coca-Cola: From Medicinal Tonic to Global Icon

Formulated in 1886 by pharmacist John Stith Pemberton, Coca-Cola was initially marketed as a “patent medicine” intended to relieve headaches and digestive problems. Today, with no therapeutic claims, it is one of the most recognizable beverages on the planet.

Salicylic Acid and the Birth of Aspirin

In 1884, German chemist Friedrich von Heyden obtained one of the first patents for the industrial production of salicylic acid, a derivative of willow bark with analgesic and antipyretic properties. Later, in 1890, the Bayer company registered the patent for diquinoliline in Spain, helping to establish a model for reliable and standardized medications.

Ceregumil: Tradition and Modernity

In 1907, pharmacist Bernabé Fernández developed Ceregumil, a nutritional tonic designed to improve digestion, made from grains, legumes, and honey. Registered as a trademark in 1911, the company has expanded internationally and today offers modern dietary supplements tailored to today’s needs.

In addition, the archives contain historical records from other pioneering brands, such as Listerine, Merck, Wellcome, and Glaxo, which helped shape the pharmaceutical industry in the 20th century.

Industrial Property as a Driver of Pharmaceutical Innovation

The shift from unproven advertising remedies to regulated medications was made possible by a combination of three key factors:

  1. Rigorous scientific research: Clinical trials have demonstrated the efficacy and safety of these medications.
  2. Patent protection: It ensured investment in development and competitiveness in the market.
  3. Robust health regulations: These established standards for quality and transparency that bolstered consumer confidence.

The social change brought about by this model led society to move beyond “miracle cures” and demand precisely what we now recognize as the fundamental pillars of pharmaceutical innovation: safe and effective medicines, protected by intellectual property rights and backed by responsible health regulations. Today, although the sector has made progress, these principles remain essential and ensure that innovation is sustainable.

Elisa Prieto, Head of Knowledge Management at Elzaburu

The General Court Examines EU Consumers' Perception of Chinese Characters and the Relevant Criteria for Assessing Bad Faith

  • Extending the protection of a national trademark by registering it as an EU trademark is part of a company's standard business strategy
  •  The fact that a party acts dishonestly in one context does not necessarily mean that the party acts in bad faith in a different case
  •  The Chinese characters in question are perceived as abstract symbols with no meaning or as decorative elements that refer to China or Asia

In the judgment in Guangzhou Wanglaoji Grand Health Co., Ltd. v. EUIPO ( Joined Cases T-121/24 to T-127/24 and T-129/24), the General Court reiterated the relevant factors for assessing bad faith at the time of filing an application. A separate judgment in the Case T-128/24 (involving the same parties to the proceedings) addressed the additional issue of the re-filing of the trademark.

Background

The contested applications were EU trademarks consisting of three Chinese characters, “王老吉,” and a Latin transcription of the sign’s Mandarin pronunciation (“Wang Lao Ji”).

The contested applications were filed in 2009, 2010, and 2014 and related to goods and services in classes 5, 29, 30, 32, 33, and 35. These applications were owned by the intervening party, Multi Access Ltd.

On July 10, 2018, the plaintiff, Guangzhou Wanglaoji Grand Health Co., Ltd., filed applications for a declaration of invalidity of the contested trademarks with respect to all goods and services for which they were protected. The ground for invalidity invoked was that set forth in Article 52(1)(b) of Regulation 207/2009 (now Article 59(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001).

The EUIPO Invalidity Division dismissed the requests for invalidation, finding that the intervening party’s bad faith at the time of filing the contested trademarks had not been proven.

On February 8, 2023, the petitioner filed appeals against the decisions issued by the Cancellation Division. The Board of Appeals dismissed the appeals, concluding as follows:

  • The applicant and the intervenor had a complex and long-standing relationship. The intervenor knew that the contested trademarks were being marketed and used in China by the applicant prior to the filing date of the registration applications.
  • At the very least, in 2002, the plaintiff’s group of companies should have known that the intervening party’s companies were using trademarks in Europe consisting of the three Chinese characters in question.
  • There was nothing to suggest that the market separation between the applicant and the intervenor in 1913 would have prevented the latter from lawfully registering and using the disputed trademarks in the European Union.
  • Given that the intervening party and its companies had informed the plaintiff’s companies, through license agreements signed in 1995 and 2002, that they were using trademarks consisting of the three Chinese characters abroad (including Europe), such transparency could not be reconciled with the assertion that the intervening party had acted in bad faith with the aim of unduly taking advantage of the plaintiff’s reputation.
  • The intervening party’s intent at the time of registration of the contested trademarks was part of a normal business strategy, since it was the legitimate owner of trademarks consisting of the three Chinese characters in Hong Kong, and it had not been shown that it had been prevented from extending its rights to other jurisdictions.

Judgments

With regard to the allegations of bad faith on the part of the applicant at the time the applications were filed, the General Court upheld the Board of Appeal’s decision and dismissed the action, finding that the trademark owner’s fraudulent intent in filing the applications had not been proven.

The parties had signed a joint-use agreement in 1913, under which both held rights to the same trademark consisting of the three Chinese characters. Therefore, the Court held that both were historically legitimate owners of trademarks consisting of those three Chinese characters in third countries. Since that agreement made no reference to the European Union, in the context of the examination of the registration of that trademark in the European Union, the“first-to-file”principle must be applied.

The principle of priority based on registration is qualified by Article 52(1)(b) of Regulation 207/2009, pursuant to which a European Union trademark must be declared invalid, upon request to the EUIPO, when the applicant acted in bad faith at the time of filing the application. Since the intervener was the owner of national rights in two EU Member States (France and the United Kingdom, prior to Brexit) and it could not be demonstrated that the intervening party’s predecessors were not entitled to apply for trademark registration outside Hong Kong (such as those filed in France and the United Kingdom in 1992), the Court agreed with the EUIPO Board of Appeal in finding that extending the protection of a national trademark by registering it as a European Union trademark is part of a company’s normal business strategy.

The Court noted that the European Union trademark system is an autonomous system and did not take into account the decisions issued by national authorities in third countries (such as China and the Philippines), in which the intervening party was found guilty of bribery, misleading advertising, unfair competition, and bad faith in filing another trademark application (distinct from the trademarks at issue in this case). The Court held that the fact that the party had acted dishonestly in a different context did not necessarily mean that it was automatically acting in bad faith when filing the applications for registration of the contested trademarks in the European Union.

These conclusions were consistent with those reached in the judgments handed down in the joined cases T-121/24 through T-127/24 and T-129/24, as well as in Case T-128/24. The latter was dealt with separately due to an additional ground of appeal concerning the re-filing of trademarks.

In that case, the intervening party had filed an application for registration of a European Union trademark in Classes 5, 30, and 35 that was nearly identical to an earlier European Union trademark. It was filed six days before the grace period for the prior trademark expired and differed from it only in insignificant visual elements. The intervener argued that the prior trademark depicted the three Chinese characters in poor quality and that the new application was intended to modernize that mark.

The Court held that there is nothing in European Union trademark law that prohibits the refiling of an application for registration. Therefore, the mere fact of refiling the application cannot, in and of itself, establish bad faith at the time of filing.

While it is true that, according to case law, a trademark consisting entirely of letters protects the term specified in the application and not the specific graphic or stylistic elements present in that mark, and that the representation of a word mark is not generally of such a nature as to alter its distinctive character, in the present case the appellant had not demonstrated that a significant portion of the relevant public in the European Union was aware of the meaning of the three Chinese characters.

Consequently, the Court found that the relevant public would perceive the signs as devoid of any meaning, as abstract signs, or as signs consisting of decorative elements referring to China or Asia. Thus, the intervener’s attempt to register the disputed trademark in a higher-quality format—which constitutes a modernization of the earlier trademark—was justified by customary business practices. Consequently, the allegation of “repeated conduct” as an indicator of bad faith was rejected.

Concluding Remarks

These rulings highlight the importance of the evidence submitted in support of an application to declare a European Union trademark invalid. The Court reaffirmed the autonomy of the EU trademark system and the non-binding nature of decisions issued by courts and intellectual property offices in third countries. It also emphasized the need to demonstrate the applicant’s bad faith by providing solid and well-founded evidence, rather than relying on mere assumptions or allegations.

The Court also provided valuable guidance regarding practices considered part of a legitimate business strategy, defining the scope of what it considers to be a “modernization” of an already registered trademark when such registrations are in a language that is not an official language of the European Union; consumers’ perception of such trademarks, will be characterized by the belief that they are meaningless terms, abstract signs, or mere decorative elements referring to China or Asia.

Sara Navarro, Senior Associate in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu.

Originally published on WTR on July 28, 2025.