A brand is one of the most valuable intangible assets for any company, not only because it identifies its products or services, but also because it serves as a vehicle for building reputation, conveying values, and fostering consumer loyalty.
But not all trademarks are the same, and a distinction is increasingly being made between those considered traditional—such as names and logos—and those considered non-traditional, which include shapes, colors, sounds, movement, or even specific placements of the mark on a product.
These non-traditional trademarks offer new opportunities for differentiation, but they also entail greater legal and strategic challenges when it comes to protecting them. In this guide, we explain the different types of trademarks, how they are classified, and what you need to consider if you want to successfully register a non-traditional trademark.
A brand is a symbol that distinguishes a company’s products or services and sets them apart from those of its competitors. More than just a logo or a name, a brand represents a company’s commercial identity and becomes a vital asset for its market positioning.
For a trademark to be registered, it must meet two fundamental requirements:
The advantage of registering a trademark is that its protection can potentially be indefinite, provided it is renewed periodically (every 10 years in the European Union and Spain), unlike other industrial property rights such as designs, whose protection in our country lasts for 5 years and can be extended to a maximum of 25 years.
Brands can be divided into two broad groups: traditional and non-traditional. Below, we describe each type with illustrative examples.
These are the ones consumers think of when they hear the word “brand,” as they represent the options that are best known and most widely used by companies. They include:
Non-traditional trademarks are used to protect visual, sensory, or presentation elements that do not fit into conventional categories but may still be capable of fulfilling the distinctive function of a trademark.
They protect the distinctive shape of a product or its packaging, provided that it deviates from standard designs and is not solely based on a technical or functional purpose. Examples include iconic perfume bottles, as well as unique shapes of handbags, shoes, or beverages.
Three-dimensional trademarks also include trade dress, which protects the overall appearance of a retail establishment (shelf layout, aisles, color schemes, etc.) when that configuration serves to identify a commercial source.
They protect the specific placement of a symbol on a product. Some examples of this type of non-traditional trademark are:
They feature the systematic repetition of a graphic or ornamental motif. Take Louis Vuitton, for example, which has succeeded in creating a highly recognizable pattern through the use of its logo, or Burberry with its classic “Check” pattern.
They can refer to a single color or to a combination of colors in specific proportions (both in terms of color distribution and the relative weights of each color).
Registering a trademark based on a single color poses a particular challenge, due to the limited availability of shades and the need to avoid monopolies on basic colors. For this reason, only those trademarks that have achieved a high degree of recognition and association in the market are granted registration.
Some companies that have achieved this include Milka, with its traditional purple color, and 3M, with the classic yellow color of its Post-it notes.
They include melodies, sounds, or jingles that identify a product or service—for example, Mercadona’s sung slogan or the iconic MGM lion’s roar.
They protect visual animations that depict a moving symbol, but without sound.
They combine video and audio into a single file. An example would be the opening sequence of a TV show or streaming platform.
They preserve three-dimensional visual effects such as glare, reflections, and contrasts that vary depending on the viewing angle.
Although applications have been filed both at the national level and within the European Union, these trademarks have not yet been accepted in practice, as they do not meet the requirement of clear, precise, objective, and lasting representation. Therefore, at present—and at least until technology exists that allows for their objective assessment—it is not possible to register smells, tastes, or tactile sensations as trademarks.
Non-traditional trademarks present specific challenges when they are filed and examined by intellectual property offices, because their form of expression often differs from traditional signs and from what we have come to recognize as a trademark.
These challenges stem from three key factors:
The sign must fulfill its function as a trademark; that is, it must—as we have seen—have representational capacity (it must be capable of being clearly and easily perceived) and distinctive capacity (it must identify the business origin of the product or service).
Furthermore, although in theory the requirements are identical to those for traditional trademarks, it is now required that the sign differ from what is customary in the sector to which it belongs. This means that it must not be a shape, color, or arrangement commonly found on the market, but must stand out for its originality or exclusive use.
During the trademark application process, it is possible to demonstrate that the mark has acquired distinctiveness through prior use in the market. This is known as “secondary meaning”: because consumers have repeatedly seen that sign associated with a specific business, they recognize it as indicative of a specific source.
Special care must be taken with certain absolute prohibitions that are frequently applied to non-traditional trademarks. In particular, when the sign consists exclusively of a shape or feature that:
In certain industries, it is often necessary to determine which form of protection is most appropriate: whether to register a sign as a design or as a trademark.
Both options are perfectly valid, but they have different legal statuses:
The key is to analyze each specific situation and determine the most appropriate form of protection based on the commercial objectives and the nature of the mark.
Non-traditional trademarks allow companies to protect distinctive and innovative assets that form part of a company’s visual or sensory identity. However, registering them requires a very careful legal strategy, with special attention paid to proving distinctiveness, use in the marketplace, and overcoming absolute prohibitions.
At ELZABURU, we help our clients identify the most appropriate form of protection for each asset, taking into account its role in the market and the applicable regulations in each jurisdiction. Therefore, we are committed to designing customized strategies that are tailored to the specific needs and objectives of each case.
Cristina Velasco, Senior Associate in the Trademark Practice Group at ELZABURU.
Registering a trademark is essential for protecting the identity of your company, your products, or your services. This guide explains how to register your trademark in Spain, how to extend its protection throughout Europe or internationally, what can be registered, the legal implications of using a trademark, and answers to the most common questions about trademark protection.
A trademark is a symbol that identifies a company's products or services and distinguishes them from those of other companies. It can consist of words, images, logos, shapes, colors, or sounds.
Registering a trademark grants its owner the right to take legal action against third parties who use identical or similar marks in the same commercial field.
Any distinctive sign that identifies the business origin of a product or service may be registered. This includes:
The mark must be distinctive; that is, it must be capable of identifying and distinguishing the product or service from others on the market, without merely describing its characteristics, qualities, or nature.
No. To register a trademark, you must specify the specific goods or services to which it will apply, in accordance with the Nice Classification, which divides activities into 45 classes.
Although a single trademark may be registered in multiple classes, protection is limited solely to the specified goods or services and does not extend to other categories not included in the registration, except for well-known trademarks, whose protection may extend to related goods or services depending on their degree of recognition.
Although it is possible to use a trademark without registering it, it is not advisable to do so without first checking for prior registrations. Use without registration does not confer exclusive rights; therefore, if another person has previously registered the trademark, that person could take legal action for infringement against the owner using an unregistered mark.
In Spain and the European Union, exclusive rights to a trademark are primarily acquired through registration. Therefore, to effectively protect your trademark and avoid legal risks, it is advisable to register it before beginning commercial use.
Once registered, the trademark has an initial term of five years during which its use is not mandatory.
However, once this period has elapsed, the owner must make effective and genuine use of the trademark to maintain its protection. If the trademark is not used continuously and in accordance with the registration, a third party may request that the trademark be revoked for lack of use.
Valid uses include, among others:
In addition, in opposition or invalidation proceedings, it may be necessary to submit evidence of use to prove the actual use of the trademark.
If you discover that a third party is using a mark that is identical or similar to yours for the same or related goods or services, you can take various legal actions, including:
Registering a trademark in Spain is an administrative process handled by the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM). It is essential to carry out this process with rigor and precision to avoid rejections by the OEPM, potential oppositions from third parties, or invalidation proceedings, if applicable.
Before applying for registration, it is recommended that you search the OEPM database to check whether there are any identical or similar trademarks already registered that could pose an obstacle to your registration.
Although the applicant may be able to conduct this search on their own, it is recommended that the search be carried out by a specialized professional to prevent the trademark application from facing oppositions from third parties due to a conflict with a prior trademark.
Trademark protection is not universal; rather, it is limited to the goods or services specified in the application, in accordance with the Nice Classification, which is divided into:
Choosing the correct classes is essential: registering a trademark in inappropriate classes may leave its actual scope of use unprotected and lead to disputes with third parties.
The application is filed with the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM) and must include:
An incomplete or incorrect application may result in delays, objections, or even denial of registration.
After the application is filed, the OEPM conducts an admissibility and formal review to verify that the legal requirements are met:
If the application is in order, it will be accepted for processing.
If the application contains formal defects, the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM) grants a period of time to correct them; if they are not corrected within that time, the application will be deemed withdrawn.
Once the application has been accepted for processing, it is published in the BOPI. This publication serves two purposes:
During this period, owners of other earlier trademarks may oppose the registration if they believe that the new trademark infringes on their rights.
In that case, an adversarial proceeding is initiated in which both parties present arguments and evidence.
If no objections are filed against the application, or if any objections filed are dismissed, the case will proceed to the next stage.
If there are no obstacles, the OEPM issues a decision granting the trademark and publishes it as granted in the BOPI. From that point on:
Once granted, it is essential to:
If you need to protect your trademark in several European countries, you can apply for a European Union Trademark (EUTM) with the EUIPO (EU Intellectual Property Office).
Advantages:
It is not a “global trademark,” but WIPO allows you to seek protection in multiple countries through a single international application, thereby simplifying the process and reducing costs.
Given that this is a very specific type of registration, the trademark owner should, with professional advice, evaluate the applicant’s expansion plans as well as the commercial interest in each country to determine whether the best approach for their protection strategy is to opt for the WIPO route or for national registrations in each territory.
Key Requirements:
Advantage: You centralize the application and management of renewals, but the legal effects continue to depend on each country.
The trademark registration system in Spain and the European Union allows for the protection of various types of distinctive signs, which are commonly classified as traditional and non-traditional trademarks, depending on how they are represented.
These are the most common and are based on signs that can be seen or read:
These are symbols that are not necessarily represented in a conventional visual way. Some examples include:
The law requires that the representation of the trademark be clear, precise, complete, durable, and objective, so that the authorities and the public can determine exactly the scope of the protection granted.
Depending on the type of trademark, the representation may be graphic, auditory, audiovisual, or in the form of digital files, in accordance with the formats and technical requirements established by the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM).
After the trademark is granted:
At Elzaburu, we have been advising companies, entrepreneurs, universities, and public entities on the protection and defense of their distinctive marks for over 160 years. Our specialized team guides you through the entire process: from filing a trademark application in Spain, Europe, or internationally, to monitoring, renewing, and defending your trademark through administrative or judicial proceedings.
Enrique Jacobo, Attorneys and Specialists in the Trademark Department at Elzaburu.
Legislative developments in the field of industrial property are an essential factor to consider when seeking to maintain or create a competitive advantage in any market. Recently, countries such as Libya, Iraq, Turkey, and the Bahamas have introduced significant reforms that directly impact how trademark registrations are managed and maintained within their respective systems.
One of the most notable developments in Libya is the significant increase in official fees for trademark renewals, which has led to a sharp rise in the cost of maintaining trademarks for their owners.
Specifically, the official trademark renewal fees have risen to over 20,000 USD—that is, more than 2,000 USD for each year the trademark is in force.
It is essential to review renewal deadlines and budget for the corresponding costs well in advance. This change particularly affects foreign trademark owners, who will need to carefully evaluate whether maintaining their registrations is feasible given the new costs. Additionally, it is important to consider the specific characteristics of the Arab legal environment when developing a trademark strategy in the region.
Since January 2025, the Iraqi Trademark Office has implemented the 11th edition of the Nice Classification, bringing it into line with international standards. This step allows applicants to seek protection in all 45 classes, including service classes, thereby expanding the range of options available to trademark owners.
This transition requires the reclassification of goods and services in registered trademarks, pending applications, and future renewals. The office has published specific guidelines, and compliance with them will be mandatory in every new proceeding.
Given this update, trademark owners are encouraged more than ever to plan ahead for expirations or other relevant actions. The goal is to review and adapt to the new classification well in advance, thereby avoiding delays or issues in trademark proceedings in Iraq.
As of March 2025, Turkey has introduced an administrative procedure that allows for the filing of applications to cancel trademarks for nonuse directly with the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TPTO), without the need to go to court or engage in litigation.
This new approach offers a faster, more cost-effective, and more efficient alternative to the traditional judicial process, making it a useful tool for optimizing trademark management in Turkey.
The Bahamas has amended its trademark legislation with the entry into force, on February 1, 2025, of a new Trademark Act. Among the most significant changes is the ability—which did not previously exist—to register service marks.
Although certain operational aspects still need to be worked out, the new regulations pave the way for companies in sectors such as tourism, financial services, and hospitality to strengthen their brand presence in the country. In any case, it is advisable to proceed with caution until the practical implementation of this reform is fully established.
The reforms in these four countries underscore the importance of staying up to date on legal changes that affect the registration and maintenance of trademarks abroad. These adjustments—whether for economic, technical, or procedural reasons—require us to review our strategies and plan ahead.
At ELZABURU, we have a team with extensive experience advising companies on brand management abroad, helping our clients adapt to new legal environments safely and efficiently.
Cristina Arroyo, Director oftheInternationalBrands Divisionat ELZABURU
On June 4, 2025, the General Court of the European Union (GCEU) upheld the validity of two Community designs registered by Decathlon for its popular Easybreath snorkel mask, dismissing the invalidity actions filed by the German company Delta-Sport Handelskontor GmbH. The decision, set forth in cases T-1060/23 and T-1061/23, provides up-to-date guidance on how functionality, distinctiveness, and overall impression are analyzed in the protection of industrial designs in the EU. For those who manage design portfolios or litigate in the field of industrial property, these rulings are essential.
These judgments by the General Court of the European Union mark a significant milestone in the interpretation of Regulation (EC) No. 6/2002 on Community designs. In them, the Court addressed two key issues raised by Delta-Sport: whether the characteristics of the design were dictated exclusively by its technical function and whether the designs lacked individual character due to prior disclosures.
The TGUE concluded that certain design elements, such as the oval shape of the frame and the “X”-shaped strap attachment, were not determined solely by technical function but also reflected the designer’s aesthetic choices. Furthermore, the fact that there were viable alternatives for fulfilling the same technical function reinforced the idea that there was room for creativity.
With regard to distinctiveness, the Court held that, although there were similarities to earlier designs (including Decathlon’s own patents), the differences in elements such as the shape of the frame, the colors, the strap, and the tube cap were sufficient to create a distinct overall impression on the informed user.


002340224-0001
002526699-0001
Source images of the judgments: Cases T-1060/23 and T-1061/23
Some design elements, such as the oval frame and the way the strap attaches to the head, were not driven solely by technical requirements. These details also reflect aesthetic decisions made by the designer.
Even acknowledging similarities with prior patents and utility models, the TGUE concludes that the formal and visual differences are sufficient to create a distinct overall impression on the “informed user.” The Chamber emphasizes that the comparison is made as a whole, without breaking down individual components.
The Court also considered whether there were viable alternatives to the contested design that could perform the same technical function. This was key to demonstrating that the designer had a margin of creative freedom, thereby reinforcing the validity of the aesthetic choices made. The presence on the market of designs featuring different technical solutions made it possible to reject the claim that the contested elements were mandatory.
The TGUE carefully examined the evidence submitted by Delta-Sport, including images of prior products and technical documents. However, it determined that this evidence was insufficient to demonstrate a lack of novelty or distinctiveness, as it did not reproduce the same essential elements with the necessary precision and clarity. The comparative analysis focused on the perception of the informed user, not on a detailed technical analysis.
These rulings confirm that aesthetics matter and that designers have the right to protect their creative expression, even in functional products. This is particularly relevant for companies with extensive design portfolios, such as Decathlon, which must anticipate potential conflicts and justify the design decisions they make.
Judgments T-1060/23 and T-1061/23 confirm that, in sectors with common technical solutions, the designer’s creative scope and the informed user’s perspective remain decisive for protecting a design in the EU. For this reason, when developing defense strategies against invalidation actions for Community designs, it is important to always combine technical expertise, creativity, and market evidence.
At Elzaburu, we assist companies and designers throughout the entire process of managing, protecting, defending, and internationalizing their industrial designs (across all sectors and for all types of products).
Paloma Querol, Associate and Attorney at the ELZABURU office in Valencia.
In Lotus Bakeries v. EUIPO (Case T-1096/23), the General Court addressed the absolute ground for refusal set forth in Article 7(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, which prohibits the registration of trademarks that lack distinctive character.
On February 22, 2022, Lotus Bakeries filed an application to register the following color trademark (EU trademark application No. 018659684) for goods in Class 30:

On February 24, 2023, the EUIPO examiner rejected the application on the basis of Article 7(1)(b), finding that it lacked distinctiveness.
Lotus Bakeries filed an appeal against the examiner's decision. That appeal was dismissed by the EUIPO Board of Appeal, which found that the two colors (red and white) and their combination lacked distinctiveness.
Lotus Bakeries filed an appeal with the General Court, alleging infringement of:
The General Court confirmed that the trademark applied for lacked any distinctive character. The Court found that the Board of Appeal had conducted a reasoned and non-contradictory analysis of the sign when it examined:
The Court found that the overall impression of the mark applied for had been correctly assessed, even though the Board of Appeal had first analyzed the colors (red and white) separately. The mark applied for consists of a simple combination of two colors arranged in a series of outline-less stripes, such that the sign could be used for advertising or promotional purposes.
With regard to Lotus Bakeries’ claim that the Board of Appeal misapplied the case law, in particular the judgment Libertel (Case C-104/01, May 6, 2003), the Court held that the Board was correct to refer to other relevant case law concerning color combinations, such as Heidelberger Bauchemie (Case C-49/02, June 24, 2004).
Lotus Bakeries also argued that the Board of Appeal had taken into account the descriptive nature of the mark applied for (Article 7(1)(c)), whereas its decision was based solely on Article 7(1)(b). The Court found that this was not the case. In essence, the Board had refused the mark applied for because the use of the colors red and white was common in the market and because their combination would not allow the mark to be perceived as an indication of commercial origin. Its additional considerations regarding the possible perception of the color combination as decorative, promotional, or functional were not made for the purpose of analyzing a potential generic nature, but rather to determine to what extent the relevant public would perceive the trademark as serving a function other than that of an indication of commercial origin.
Accordingly, the Court agreed with the Board of Appeal that the trademark applied for fell within the grounds for refusal set forth in Article 7(1)(b), and that, consequently, Lotus Bakeries could not validly rely on prior decisions of the EUIPO, the EUIPO Guidelines, or its training materials to challenge that conclusion.
This ruling sheds light on the assessment of the distinctiveness of trademarks consisting of a combination of colors, taking into account not only the trademark itself but also the market in which it operates, in order to determine its ability to convey information to consumers, particularly regarding the commercial origin of the goods and/or services. It also provides valuable guidance on the formal aspects of decisions, including all elements relating to their reasoning and the application of the principles of proportionality and equal treatment.
Patricia Gómez, Junior Associate in the Trademark Practice Group at Elzaburu.
The legal framework governing the protection of industrial designs in the European Union has been updated with the entry into force of Regulation (EU) 2024/2822 and Directive (EU) 2024/2823. This legislative reform marks a significant milestone in the harmonization and modernization of the system for registering and protecting industrial designs in Europe, as the previous directive dated back to 1998.
With this reform, the European Union seeks to facilitate access to industrial design protection, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), while adapting to the technological and economic challenges of the digital age.
One of the major innovations in the industrial design law is the broadening of the definition of “product” eligible for protection. From now on, it will be possible to register not only designs applied to physical objects, but also those that:
Protection is limited to the features visible in the representations of the registered design. However, those features need not be visible at any specific moment or in any specific situation of use. There is only one exception: in the case of components of complex products, protection applies only to the elements visible during normal use of the product.
The clause regarding the repair of replacement parts becomes mandatory for all European Union member states. This harmonizes the legal situation regarding the use of protected designs to repair a complex product and thereby restore its original appearance, when the design is incorporated into an object that constitutes a component of a complex product on whose appearance the protected design of the component depends.
Another critical issue is the emergence of technologies such as 3D printing. To prevent infringements, the new regulations clarify that: “the creation, downloading, copying, and making available of any medium or software that records the design for the purpose of reproducing a product that infringes on the protected design,” without authorization, is strictly prohibited.
The regulations also call for an update to the formats allowed for submitting designs. Pending official confirmation, it is expected that videos and 3D images will be accepted as alternative means of representation to the traditional seven static views.
Significant changes have been made to the fee schedule:
This reform will be implemented in two phases:
For their part, EU member states will have until December 9, 2027, to incorporate the changes from the new directive into their respective national laws.
Although this is not a regulatory revolution, this update represents a substantial improvement in the legal protection of industrial designs in the European Union. The filing and registration system remains in place, and substantive examination of designs continues to be conducted only in cases where an application for a declaration of invalidity is filed against a registered design.
Similarly, we won't know until next year how the key aspects of the second phase will play out. Some of these changes could have a significant impact in practice, both for designers and for companies that use industrial designs as a competitive asset.
Ultimately, users of the design protection system in the European Union will have new legal tools at their disposal that will allow them to protect their creations more effectively and flexibly in an increasingly digital and globalized market.
At Elzaburu, we will continue to provide updates on how the practical implementation of these reforms is progressing, especially as we look ahead to the second phase, which will take effect in 2026.
Pedro Saturio, Associate Partner in the Patent Practice Group at Elzaburu.
Knowing a brand's value is key to understanding its impact on the market and its relevance to consumers. The world's most valuable brands stand out not only for their financial success but also for how consumers perceive them.
Currently, according to Brand Finance’s “Global 500” report, there has been a growing increase in the value of some Spanish brands, which are achieving an increasingly competitive position on the global stage.
Banco Santander ranks as the most valuable Spanish brand, coming in at No. 93 on the global ranking. Its brand value has increased by 16%, reaching $21.8 billion.
The fashion brand Zara, part of the Inditex Group, ranks 116th, with an 11% increase in its brand value, which now stands at $18.1 billion.
BBVA 's market value has increased by 28%, reaching $9.2 billion and placing it at No. 247 on the ranking.
Movistar ranks 273rd, with a brand value of $8.6 billion, after growing 12%.
CaixaBank has seen its brand value grow by 25%, reaching $7.1 billion and ranking 329th globally.
Mercadona has managed to rank 359th in the global ranking.
Rounding out the list of Spanish brands that have grown by 10%, reaching a value of $5.8 billion.

Source: Brand Finance Global 500 2025
Brands face numerous challenges, ranging from technological changes and geopolitical uncertainty to evolving consumer expectations. Success lies in adapting quickly to these challenges while aligning brand strategy with financial goals.
Some of the factors that have contributed most to the increase in the value of Spanish brands are:
The rise of Spanish brands in the “Global 500” ranking underscores the importance of managing intangible assets in an increasingly competitive market. These companies’ ability to innovate, expand internationally, and build trust among consumers has been key to their success.
As Spain's most valuable brands continue to rise on the global stage, it is essential to remain committed to protecting industrial and intellectual property.
At Elzaburu, we are committed to helping companies strengthen and protect their brand value, ensuring their sustainable growth in an increasingly digital and globalized world.
Lucía Palomino, attorneys and specialists in the Trademark Department at Elzaburu.
In the competitive world of wine, a brand represents much more than just a name: it is a promise of quality, a story, and a bridge to consumers. However, registering and protecting a wine brand in international markets is not simply an administrative formality. It is a comprehensive strategy that combines legal considerations, identity, and differentiation.
Using the Madrid System can simplify protection in multiple countries. However, it is essential to keep in mind that some markets, such as the United States and China, have specific requirements and deadlines that may require additional steps.
Many wineries have additional product lines, such as limited editions or premium wines, that require specific protection. In addition, registering domain names related to the brand helps prevent conflicts in the digital realm.
Wine brands are often built around stories related to family tradition, terroir, or production methods. These narratives should not only be part of the branding but also protected by intellectual property rights.
Beyond legal protection, a brand must stand out visually and emotionally. This is especially true in the wine industry, where consumers often make decisions based on cultural, visual, and storytelling elements.
Ultimately, registering and marketing a wine brand in international markets is a challenge that goes beyond legal considerations. It requires a strategic vision that combines legal protection, innovative design, and an authentic narrative. Doing so not only ensures the brand’s expansion and protection against potential counterfeits but also strengthens its market position.
Miguel Ángel Medina, Associate Partner in the Trademark Practice Group
The Enlarged Board of Appeal of the EUIPO has issued its decision in Case R 2307/2020-G, assessing the absolute ground for refusal under Article 7(1)(f) of Regulation 2017/1001, which prohibits the registration of trademarks that are contrary to public policy or accepted principles of morality. The decision includes findings on the standards for determining accepted principles of morality, the relevant public when assessing this ground for refusal, and the role of freedom of expression.
Background
On May 5, 2020, Turner Broadcasting System Europe Limited filed an application to register the word mark MARICÓN PERDIDO as an EU trademark, seeking protection for goods and services in Classes 9 and 41: audiovisual products and entertainment services. It is worth noting that the trademark application was filed before the premiere of the popular television show *Maricón Perdido* on June 21, 2021.
On November 25, 2020, the EUIPO examiner rejected the application in its entirety pursuant to Article 7(1)(f), in conjunction with Article 7(2). The decision was based on the argument that the mark meant “total faggot” and was a vulgar and offensive expression. The examiner considered that this sign would cause offense not only to the consumers for whom the goods and services were intended, but also to people who might come across it by chance in their daily lives.
On December 4, 2020, the petitioner appealed the decision. His main argument was that, although MARICÓN PERDIDO was “a homophobic expression used in Spain to describe men who could not be reeducated to be heterosexual,” it had evolved into an ironic expression used by the gay community itself, which has adopted the term “Maricón.”
Given the complexity of the case, the Board of Appeals referred it to the Enlarged Board of Appeals. In a decision issued on November 25, 2024, the appeal was dismissed.
Decision
The Enlarged Chamber upheld the examiner’s opinion, concluding that the trademark applied for would offend a significant portion of the general Spanish public, as it is considered a homophobic slur and, therefore, contrary to human dignity and accepted principles of morality.
In reaching this conclusion, the Enlarged Chamber took into account the criteria established in the FACK JU GÖHTE (Case C-240/18 P) and COVIDIOT (Case R 260/2021-G) cases, which provide guidelines on determining accepted principles of morality and clarify the role of freedom of expression in trademark proceedings.
With regard to the applicant’s arguments concerning the incorrect application of this absolute ground for refusal, the Enlarged Chamber noted the following:
Comment
As in the previous case before the Enlarged Board of Appeal (see COVIDIOT), this decision clarifies the factors to be considered when refusing to register a mark on the grounds that it violates accepted principles of morality. Furthermore, it provides useful criteria for assessing the relevant public when applying this ground for refusal and defines what is considered morally acceptable according to normal standards of tolerance and sensitivity.
The fact that the trademark application was filed before the premiere of the television show *Maricón Perdido* may have influenced the Expanded Chamber’s decision. Based on the evidence provided by the applicant, the show was very well received by its audience, and the irony in its title was highlighted. However, this did not prevent the trademark from being deemed offensive, especially when used by people outside the LGBTQ+ community.
Pamela Olivos Reyes, Associate in the Trademark Practice Group.
The Duchess of Sussex, Meghan Markle, recently announced her new business venture: “As Ever, ” a brand about which few details are known but which has already sparked controversy in Spain. The reason: its logo bears a resemblance to the coat of arms of the City Council of Porreres, a small town in the Balearic Islands.
Far from announcing legal action, the municipality has opted for a diplomatic strategy: inviting Meghan Markle to visit Porreres. However, this case raises a legal issue regarding industrial property and trademark registration in the European Union (EU).
The European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) examines each application according to strict criteria to avoid conflicts with preexisting marks. In this case, the viability of the “As Ever” trademark could be compromised due to its similarity to the coat of arms of the Porreres City Council, which opens the door to potential objections based on current regulations.
Article 6 of the Paris Convention prohibits the registration of trademarks that incorporate emblems, coats of arms, and official symbols of member states and government organizations without their consent. In Spain, there are currently 14 symbols protected under this provision, but the coat of arms of Porreres is not included on this official list.
However, the EU Trademark Regulation introduces another relevant protection mechanism in this case. According to Article 7(1)(I), the registration of trademarks containing symbols of special public interest may also be refused. The Porreres City Council could use this criterion to present arguments against the trademark application, asserting that its coat of arms has historical and cultural value. It could also rely on any other claim demonstrating the existence of a special public interest and justifying its protection within the EU.
Porreres has not announced any legal measures. However, there are a few options for defending its emblem that it could consider if it decides to take action:
If the EUIPO were to decide to reject the registration of “As Ever” in Europe, Meghan Markle could continue to use her trademark outside the EU, provided there are no legal conflicts in those territories.
In this regard:
This case underscores the importance of conducting a preliminary feasibility analysis before registering a trademark, especially when there are graphic elements that could lead to conflicts with official symbols or matters of special public interest.
Paloma Querol, associate in the trademark practice group at Elzaburu