Update on the Industrial Design Protection System in China

Designs in China (referred to as “design patents” in that country) are protected under the Patent Law of the People’s Republic of China [in English]. This law took effect in 1985 and was amended in 1992, 2000, and 2008.

On June 1, 2021, a fourth reform will take effect, introducing significant changes regarding industrial designs. Indeed, it had become necessary to update certain aspects of industrial design protection in China in order to, among other things, harmonize it with the industrial design protection systems of the world’s leading offices. This will facilitate the protection of foreign designs in China while also improving the protection of Chinese applicants’ designs in other countries and offices.

lanterns, China, lights

 

This reform must also be viewed in the context of China’s preparations to accede to the Hague System for the International Protection of Industrial Designs, since, following the accessions of the EUIPO, South Korea, the U.S., and Japan, China is the only one of the IP5 countries (which includes the world’s five leading patent offices) that has not yet acceded to it.

Nor should we overlook China’s global significance in terms of the number of design applications filed. In recent years, the CNIPA has by far been the patent office that has received the largest number of design applications. For example, in both 2018 and 2019, the number of annual design applications in China exceeded 700,000, accounting for more than 50% of all design applications worldwide.

The main changes that will affect designs in China can be summarized as follows:

1. Extension of the legal term of protection for designs to 15 years.

Article 42(1) of the Patent Law extends the term of protection from 10 to 15 years, always counting from the filing date of the design application in China.

This extension of the term of protection for industrial designs in China is based on the Hague Agreement, which requires Contracting States to provide a minimum term of protection of 15 years for their national industrial designs.

2. Possibility of design protection for parts of a product.

Article 2(4) of the Patent Act has been amended to include in the definition of “design” the possibility that it may refer to “the whole or a part” of a product.

This amendment allows the scope of protection for designs to be extended to partial designs or designs of a part of a product.

Under this new provision, for example, it will be possible to protect the design of a part of a product more effectively, without having to protect the design of the entire product. Currently, the entire product must be depicted with a solid line, but after the reform, it will be possible to show only the part to be protected with a solid line and those parts of the product for which protection is not desired with a dashed line.

It is also expected that this new option for protecting partial designs or parts of a product will encourage the filing of new design applications, thereby improving protection against potential infringers. In fact, following the reform, it will only be necessary to copy the protected part (for example, the sole of a shoe or the handle of a tool)—and not the entire product—in order to take legal action against potential infringements.

This provision will bring China's practices in line with those of the other IP5 countries, since protection for the parts of a product is currently available in all of them.

3. The possibility of claiming internal priority for designs.

Article 29(2) of the Patent Law introduces the possibility of claiming domestic priority from a prior design application in China, within a period of 6 months, in order to allow for an improved filing of a subsequent design application.

Under the current system, if an applicant files a design application in China and the design undergoes improvements or modifications, a new design application must be filed. If the improved design involves only relatively minor changes, the design application would be vulnerable due to the existence of the first application.

The introduction of the option to claim internal priority for designs in China avoids these drawbacks, since once a design has been created, the applicant may file an initial design application to obtain an earlier filing date and then improve the design within 6 months of filing the initial application, claiming priority.

In summary, the reform of the industrial design protection system in China represents a significant step forward that will help encourage innovation in the field of design and improve legal certainty. Other aspects that could be modified—such as expanding the possibility of multiple design applications, or conducting a substantive examination or a search for prior designs during the processing phase—have not been included. Perhaps they will be addressed in a future reform.

Author: Pedro Saturio

The Conflict Between Legal Names and Brands (or Trade Names)

Conflicts between corporate names and trademarks (or trade names) are very common, and there has always been significant debate—both in legal doctrine and in case law—regarding the relationship and differences between these two concepts and, specifically, regarding the scope of the exclusive right conferred by a trademark (or trade name) registration as opposed to a corporate name that may be identical or similar to such marks.

registration, trademarks, differentiation, Canica, blue, center, circle

 

First, we need to clarify the differences between these various concepts:

  • The corporate name is the name used to identify companies in legal transactions (it will normally appear in company documents relating to its legal relationships, such as invoices, contracts, etc.). It is registered with the Commercial Registry, and its regulation is set forth in the Commercial Registry Regulations.
  • A trademark is the name or symbol used to identify a company’s products and services in the marketplace and distinguish them from those of other companies, and a trade name is the name or symbol used to identify a company in commercial transactions and distinguish it from other companies engaged in similar or identical activities in the marketplace. Both are registered with the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office, and registration grants the owner the exclusive right to use them in commerce.

What happens when a company name matches or resembles a registered trademark or trade name? Does that company name constitute an infringement of the latter?

The provisions of the Trademark Law that resolve this conflict are as follows:

  • Supplementary Provision 14
  • Article 34

Additional Provision 14 of the Trademark Law establishes a prohibition applicable to the Commercial Registry: commercial registry authorities shall deny the requested corporate name if it matches or is likely to cause confusion with a well-known trademark or trade name.

Under this provision, it is therefore clear that a new application for a corporate name cannot conflict with a registered trademark or trade name. But what happens when the trademark or trade name is not well-known? Or when that corporate name is already registered in the Commercial Registry? Can the owner of the trademark or trade name invoke their exclusive rights to request the cancellation of the corporate name or prevent its use?

In this other case, we must refer to Article 34 of the Trademark Law, which is the provision governing the rights conferred by the registration of a trademark or trade name. According to this provision, in order for the owner of the trademark or trade name to prohibit a third party from using a sign, several cumulative requirements must be met; of these, for the purposes of the matter at hand, we would like to highlight the following:

  • It must be used in commercial traffic.
  • And the use must be in connection with products or

It follows from the above that:

  • The mere registration of a corporate name in the Commercial Registry does not, in and of itself, constitute an infringement of a prior trademark or trade name that the owner of such rights may prohibit. It is necessary for that corporate name to be used in commercial transactions—that is, in the marketplace.
  • The mere use of a corporate name as such—that is, for its intended purpose, which is to identify the company in legal transactions—cannot constitute an infringement of a prior trademark or trade name registration that would entitle its owners to prohibit such use. The use of said corporate name must be in connection with goods or services.

Ultimately, this would constitute improper use of the corporate name, since, as noted above, that is not the purpose for which it is intended (the purposes specific to trademarks and trade names), which is to identify the company in legal transactions.

In summary, the owner of a registered trademark or trade name may prohibit the use of a corporate name provided that (in addition to other requirements regarding infringement—such as likelihood of confusion, etc.) such corporate name: (i) is used in the course of trade, and (ii) in connection with goods or services. The right to prohibit infringing use of a corporate name is also expressly provided for in Article 34.3(d) of the Trademark Law.

Furthermore, case law has confirmed the aforementioned criteria or requirements. The CJEU judgment in this matter is well-known: C-17/06 Céline of September 11, 2007, is particularly well-known; its legal principles remain in force and continue to be applied by our national courts.

Previously published in Economist & Jurist

Author: María Cadarso

Eurasian IP System: A New Trademark System in Eastern Europe

Since around 2015, a new system has been taking shape in Northern Europe that aims to harmonize and unify, to a certain extent, trademark registration in Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Russia. It is known asthe “Eurasian IP System,”or, in Spanish, the Eurasian Intellectual Property System.

The Eurasian System was established primarily within the framework of the“Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU)” and is based on the“Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union.” For now, only the five countries mentioned are members, but it is quite possible that other countries in the region will join over time.

map, world, Europe, Asia

For us Spaniards—and, in general, for the Western world—the Eastern markets on our continent may seem somewhat unfamiliar, distant, of little relevance, or very removed from our daily lives, which are so focused on the European Union and the Americas. However, globally—especially in Asia—these markets are of immense importance. The Russian market looks primarily toward Asia, and this process of integration with other countries in the region to boost their economies has been underway for many years.

The alliance among these five countries aims to establish a single free economic zone in which goods, capital, services, and people can circulate freely within a single market and under a framework of coordinated customs integration.

As far as our profession is concerned, the new trademark registration system is about to be implemented—it was originally scheduled for 2020—as yet another opportunity for trademark registration and protection, even though there are still many details to be worked out. In addition to the logical objectives of any common market, it appears that this new system also aims to streamline trademark registration in these jurisdictions.

When compared to other well-known registration systems, it would generally be more similar to the Madrid System than to the European Union trademark system or the one administered by the African Intellectual Property Organization (OAPI).  It is not a completely unified system, but rather one that allows for the obtaining of a trademark registration covering a bundle of national registrations while maintaining a certain degree of unity and centralization for certain procedures and aspects. Therefore, once this new registration system enters into force, it will constitute yet another strategic option for the protection and internationalization of trademarks.

Some details about what will become the Eurasian Trademark System are already known. Here are a few highlights:

  1. The application shall be a single application and shall be filed with any intellectual property office of the applicant's choice among those in Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Russia.
  2. One of the offices of the member states will serve as the “receiving office” and will be responsible for conducting a formal review of the application.
  3. The substantive examination will be conducted by the intellectual property office in each country.
  4. As one might expect, the official language will be Russian.
  5. For a trademark to be granted, it must be granted in all countries. In other words, even though a trademark, once granted, consists of a bundle of national registrations, it must be granted by all offices. Otherwise, it will be necessary to convert the Eurasian registration into separate national registrations.
  6. The procedure is expected to take approximately one year.
  7. There will be an opposition procedure with a 3-month deadline. The opposition must be filed with the receiving office where the application was submitted.
  8. It is expected that use of the trademark in one of the countries will serve as proof of use in the others.
  9. It is unclear which office one must file a trademark renewal application with, but it stands to reason that it must also be filed with the office that received the original trademark application.
  10. It is unknown whether the Eurasian Trademark is expected to become part of the Madrid Protocol. Therefore, it will not be possible to designate this jurisdiction through the Madrid system, at least in the short to medium term.
  11. At present, there are no courts or a unified, centralized Eurasian administrative body. Therefore, it appears that administrative matters must be addressed with the office through which the trademark application was filed, and legal matters will be heard by the competent national court.

It will be very interesting to see how this new Eurasian System and the Madrid Protocol coexist in practice. The reality is that the Madrid Protocol allows for the protection of trademarks not only in Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Russia, but also throughout virtually all of Northern Europe and much of Asia through a procedure that is partially centralized in the initial stages and currently allows for a more or less centralized management of trademark portfolios.

Author: Cristina Arroyo

Previously published in Economist & Jurist

Somalia. Somali trademark registrations are now possible

Nearly 30 years after the Somali Intellectual Property Office was closed as a result of the devastating civil war, and thanks to a painstaking but essential process of rebuilding a failed state, the Somali Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) has been established in Mogadishu.

During the years of inactivity and lack of protection in intellectual property matters, African experts advised against devoting efforts and financial investment to the protection of trademark rights in this country, as there has been a complete lack of security and guarantees of any kind. In the absence of effective legal options, some stakeholders published precautionary notices in English- and Somali-language newspapers—an informal practice of limited effectiveness in a context as complex as Somalia’s.

Despite the opening of the Registry, some reservations remain regarding the legal foundations and framework of the Somali trademark system. However, African experts are already showing openness to promoting this jurisdiction as another option in the continent’s internationalization processes. It is noted that positive progress is being made, that a certain degree of stability and recognition of the pre-federal constitution is beginning to emerge, and that SIPO has defined objectives. Everything points to the possibility of a new intellectual property law in 2021 (although timelines are uncertain in contexts such as Somalia’s) that could introduce a simple, modern trademark registration system, with English as the official language and an opposition procedure.

Regardless of the above, there are still many challenges and implications in the region that each interested party will have to assess when the time comes.

Author: Cristina Arroyo

Asia's Ongoing Process of Joining the Madrid System

On February 24, 2021, WIPO published the announcement of Pakistan’s (Islamic Republic of Pakistan) accession to the Madrid Protocol. This Asian country is the 124th member of the Madrid System. It has, of course, joined through the Madrid Protocol, and its accession is expected to take effect on May 24, 2021.

Ambassador Khalil-ur-Rahman Hashmi (left), Permanent Representative of Pakistan to the United Nations and other international organizations in Geneva, and WIPO Director General Daren Tang

Strategically located on the Asian continent, between India, Tajikistan, Afghanistan, China, Iran, the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea, and the Gulf of Oman, it is a country that has historically played a vital role in global trade and also has one of the largest and most diverse populations in the world. Despite its political and economic instability, it has grown considerably in recent years, ranking among Asia’s leading economies.

Foreign investment, at least until the COVID-19 era, had been a key driver of Pakistan’s economic development, and Pakistan’s accession to the Madrid System will undoubtedly go a long way toward simplifying the procedures for protecting the trademark rights of foreign companies and economic operators in the country once the global economic flow stabilizes.

Author: Cristina Arroyo

The Court of Justice rules for the first time on the ban regarding the “agent’s mark”

The Court of Justice issued its judgment of November 11, 2020 (C-809/18 P; MINERAL MAGIC), in which, for the first time, it had the opportunity to establish the requirements that must be met for the application of Article 8(3) of the European Union Trademark Regulation (EUTMR).

This provision—which is based on Article 6 septies of the Paris Convention (PC)—covers the situation in which an agent (a person with a commercial relationship with the owner of a foreign trademark) applies for the foreign owner’s trademark in their own name without the owner’s consent. In layman’s terms, this is known as the “unfaithful agent” scenario.

Courthouse Building

The facts underlying the judgment in question can be summarized as follows. The British company JOHN MILLS filed an application for the European Union trademark MINERAL MAGIC to distinguish various goods in Class 3. Prior to the application, there was a distribution agreement between JOHN MILLS and the U.S. firm JEROME ALEXANDER CONSULTING regarding goods marketed under the name MAGIC MINERALS BY JEROME ALEXANDER. Upon learning of the filing of the “MINERAL MAGIC” trademark, the U.S. firm filed an opposition, invoking Article 8(3) of the EU Trademark Regulation. Among other grounds, it cited the existence of the U.S. trademark registration for “MAGIC MINERALS BY JEROME ALEXANDER,” also for goods in Class 3.

The fundamental issue, which had already been addressed by the EUIPO, was whether Article 8(3) of the EU Trademark Regulation could be applied when, as in the present case, the designations of the European trademark and the U.S. trademark were not completely identical, nor were the goods covered by both trademarks identical—at least in their entirety.

Since there was no identity between the marks, the EUIPO Opposition Division rejected the U.S. firm’s claims. However, the subsequent appeal was upheld by the First Board of Appeal of the EUIPO, and as a result, the MINERAL MAGIC trademark was, at that time, refused. The Board adopted a flexible interpretation of the provision set forth in Article 8(3) of the EU Trademark Regulation, ruling that it could also apply when the marks in question were similar both in their designations and in relation to the goods they designated.

After JOHN MILLS filed the appropriate appeal, the General Court upheld it in its judgment of October 15, 2018 (T-7/17). Essentially, the General Court interprets Article 8(3) of the EUTM Regulation literally, which refers to “that mark,” implying—in the General Court’s view—that the foreign mark and the mark applied for must be the same and, consequently, identical. Furthermore, to support its position, the General Court cites the preparatory work conducted during the drafting of Draft Regulation No. 40/94 on the Community Trade Mark. Among these background materials was a document that explicitly stated that a delegation’s proposal—that the provision in question also apply to cases involving “similar” trademarks for “similar” goods—had not been accepted. In the General Court’s view, since Article 8(3) is so clear in its wording, there was no need to rely on other interpretive sources, such as Article 6f of the Paris Convention. Therefore, it held that, since there was only a mere similarity between the marks at issue, the conditions for applying Article 8(3) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation were not met.

The Constitutional Court, on the other hand, holds that in order to apply Article 8.3 of the TFEU, it is essential to take into account Article 6 septies of the GATT, since the European Union is a member of the World Trade Organization and, as such, is obligated to comply with the TRIPS Agreement, which, in turn, stipulates that Articles 1 through 12 of the GATT must be respected.

Well, although the Court of Justice acknowledges that the French version (which is the authentic one) of Article 6 septies of the CUP uses the expression“cette marque”to refer to the earlier trademark, this does not mean that the background of the provision should not be examined. In this regard, the Court of Justice states that the Proceedings of the 1958 Lisbon Conference—which was the conference at which this provision was introduced—indicate that a trademark applied for by the agent or representative of the owner of the earlier trademark may also be protected under that provision when the trademark applied for is similar to the aforementioned earlier trademark.

In other words, the Court of Justice does not take it for granted that Article 8(3) of the EUTM Regulation (and its predecessor, Article 6 septies of the CUP) applies only in cases of identical trademarks, and it already recognizes that, a priori, it may also be applied in cases of “similarity.” And in this regard—and I find this argument very convincing—the CJEU clearly states that“if Article 8(3) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation were to apply only to cases of identity between marks (including identity in use), such an interpretation would have the effect of calling into question the general concept of the European Union Trademark Regulation, insofar as it would result in the owner of the foreign trademark being deprived of the possibility of opposing, on the basis of Article 8(3), the registration of a similar trademark by his agent or representative, whereas the agent or representative, once such registration has been made, would be entitled, specifically under Article 8(1)(b), to file an opposition to the subsequent application for registration of the original trademark by that proprietor due to the similarity of that trademark to the trademark registered by the agent or representative of that same proprietor.”

Based on these arguments, the General Court grants the appeal and even addresses the merits of the case, concluding that, in the present case, the conditions for the application of Article 8.3 of the EU Trademark Regulation are met and, therefore, the trademarks are incompatible.

In short, we can conclude that this ruling is of great significance, as it confirms the requirements that must be met for the owner of a foreign trademark to prevent the registration of a subsequent trademark filed by their agent or representative. In summary, we can state that these requirements—which must all be met cumulatively—are as follows.

    1. The first requirement is that, specifically in countries where trademark rights are acquired by registration, the person seeking to assert their rights must be the owner of a trademark in a country that is a party to the Paris Convention or the World Trade Organization.

 

    1. The second requirement is that there must have been a business relationship between the trademark owners prior to the filing of the contested trademark application. In this regard, there is agreement that the terms “agent” or “representative” must be interpreted broadly, including, for example, a distributor, as in the case decided by this judgment.

 

  1. The last of the requirements—which is, in fact, the one analyzed in the judgment in question—holds that it is not essential for the conflicting trademarks to be identical; rather, the requirement may also apply in cases where there is a resemblance between the trademarks and a similarity in the goods or services claimed under both trademarks.

If these requirements are met, Articles 8.3 of the EU Trademark Regulation and 6 septies of the Spanish Trademark Code will apply, unless—as those provisions state—the agent can justify his or her actions or has authorization (which I understand must be express) from the owner of the foreign trademark.

 

Author:Jesús Gómez Montero; Former Partner at ELZABURU and Member of the Advisory Committee of the Alberto Elzaburu Foundation

 

Mandatory Use of the Registered Trademark: Some Considerations

In this post, I would like to share some thoughts on the mandatory use of registered trademarks, in light of the content of several recent rulings handed down by the judicial bodies that make up the Court of Justice of the European Union.

red car fenderIn the judgment of the Court of Justice dated October 22, 2020 (C-720/18) raised in connection with the use of FERRARI’s “Testarossa” (figurative) trademark, my attention was drawn to a reference to a treaty (the existence of which, frankly, I was unaware of) signed as far back as 1892 between Switzerland and Germany. This treaty—which, according to the ruling, is still in force—stipulates that Any adverse consequences that, under the laws of the Contracting Parties, result from the nonuse of a trademark for a certain period of time shall not apply if the trademark has been used in the territory of the other Contracting Party (Art. 5.1).

 

Based on this circumstance, the use of a German trademark in Switzerland will be valid for proving the use of a German national trademark, which, therefore, cannot be revoked even if it is not used on German territory. The resulting paradox stems from the fact that, as the ruling points out, if that same German trademark is used to oppose a new application for a European Union trademark, such opposition will not succeed if the applicant for the European Union trademark requests that proof of use of the German trademark be provided, since that use does not take place within the territory of the European Union.

Buy Infinite Eight Champagne Extra Brut 2004 | Price and Reviews at Drinks&CoAnother ruling I would like to discuss is that of the General Court dated September 23, 2020 (T-601/19) which ruled on a case involving opposition proceedings between the European Union trademark application “in·fi·ni·tu·de” and the earlier Spanish trademark “infinite,” both intended to distinguish wines. As part of those proceedings, the opponent was required to prove use of its trademark, for which it submitted various documents demonstrating that the “infinite” trademark had been used in connection with the export of wines to Canada, Puerto Rico, and the United States.

Once the use of the “infinite” trademark was admitted, the Court proceeded to assess whether there was a likelihood of confusion between the conflicting trademarks; in this regard, the Court began by determining that the relevant territory was Spain and the relevant public consisted of the general public, whose level of attention is average. The truth is that both of these circumstances may require some qualification, since, given that the trademark is Spanish, it seems appropriate that the relevant territory be Spain; however, upon closer examination, it must be acknowledged that the product is sold and consumed outside the EU, so, in the reality of the market, the likelihood of confusion—at least as assessed from the perspective of the general public—would arise in those countries, since that “general public” would consist of consumers in Canada or the United States.

Logically, such a target audience is not appropriate for analyzing a trademark conflict arising within the European Union. In cases involving use established through the export of the product to third countries, it seems more logical to assume that the relevant audience should consist of professionals involved in the import or export of the products; and such an assessment must be conducted by determining, in this case, the level of attention paid by these professionals.

FRIGIDAIREThe last of the rulings I would like to report on is the one handed down by the General Court on October 28, 2020 (T-583/19). This case concerns the FRIGIDAIRE trademark, which was partially revoked by the EUIPO because sufficient use could not be demonstrated for certain products (washing machines, dishwashers, etc.).

The trademark owner had submitted evidence of the trademark’s use to distinguish those household appliances, including, among other evidence, proof of the sale of such products for use at U.S. military bases in Belgium and Germany. However, the General Court held that in these cases there is no use within the territory of the European Union, since the areas occupied by such military bases are not part of that territory; therefore, as there is no use of the FRIGIDAIRE trademark in the European Union, it must be canceled for those products.

As can be seen, the cases addressed in the cited rulings are somewhat unusual and serve as further evidence that, when applying trademark law , any assessment must be made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the specific circumstances of each case.

Author:Jesús Gómez Montero, Former Partner at ELZABURU and Member of the Advisory Committee of the Alberto Elzaburu Foundation

 

Trinidad and Tobago: A New Country in the Americas Joins the International Trademark Registration System

The latest addition to the Madrid System, just announced, is Trinidad and Tobago, also known as Trinidad and Tabago. Interestingly, this Caribbean archipelago has a capital city whose name clearly derives from Spanish: Port of Spain.

As of October 12, 2020, Trinidad and Tobago has become the latest addition to the already long list of countries participating in the international trademark registration system. Specifically, it is the 123rd country.

On that date, October 12, the country's authorities deposited the instrument of accession to the Madrid Protocol, which will enter into force on January 12, 2021, provided that the coronavirus pandemic allows everything to be ready by then.

In principle, this is a country where certain legislative matters have already been harmonized. For example, it operates a multi-class registration system and follows the eleventh edition of the Nice Classification. The term of trademark protection is 10 years from the filing date. However, in this regard, this jurisdiction has a unique feature: when trademarks claim priority, the term is calculated from that date rather than from the date of filing of the trademark application in Trinidad and Tobago.

For certain sectors of the economy—such as the hydrocarbons, refining, and petrochemicals sectors, or the steel industry—the Madrid Protocol offers a new option for protecting their trademarks in Trinidad and Tobago.

Author: Cristina Arroyo

MESSI's Decisive Victory Over MASSI

Just when it seemed that Lionel Messi had finally stopped making headlines after a tumultuous summer, on September 17, 2020, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled in Cases C-449/18 and C-474/18 on the appeals filed by EUIPO and J.M.-E.V. e hijos S.R.L. against the judgment handed down by the General Court (GC).

As we mentioned previously, and to recap, F.C. Barcelona player Lionel Messi filed European Union trademark application No. 010181154 with EUIPO in 2011 to distinguish goods in classes 9, 25, and 28, using the following graphic:

Messi Logo

As a result of that application, the owner of the earlier European Union trademarks Nos. 3436607 and 414086 MASSI (word marks), registered in classes 25, 9, and 28, respectively, filed an opposition based on the existence of a likelihood of confusion and/or association (Article 8.1. b) of the EUTM Regulation) between the trademark applied for by Leo Messi and the earlier trademarks regarding the“MASSI” mark.

EUIPO ruled in full favor of the opposition filed by the owner of theMASSI trademarks, thereby rejecting Leo Messi’s application on the grounds that there was a likelihood of confusion between the conflicting marks. Consequently, in 2014, Lionel Messi filed an appeal against the rejection decision, but EUIPO dismissed it.

In September 2014, the applicant appealed that rejection decision before the General Court, arguing that the trademarksMESSIandMASSIwere perfectly compatible for registration purposes, since the EUIPO had failed to consider the importance of the conceptual level when analyzing the matter.

The General Court ruled on the appeal on April 28, 2018, granting the European Union trademark at issue; this decision was appealed to the Court of Cassation by both EUIPO and J.M.-E.V. e hijos S.R.L.

Well, the Supreme Court has ruled on this matter and confirmed the decision already issued by the General Court in 2018, establishing the following:

  1. In Case C-449/18 P (EUIPO), the Court of Justice held that the General Court had duly taken into account the perception of the MESSI and MASSI marks by the entire relevant public when assessing the likelihood of confusion, and not just by a portion of that public, as EUIPO had argued. This is due, in the Court of Justice’s view, to the appellant’s misinterpretation of the General Court’s judgment.
  2. With regard to Case C-474/18 P (J.M.-E.V. e hijos S.R.L.), the high court notes that, like the reputation of the earlier trademark, the potential fame of the person requesting that their name be registered as a trademark is one of the relevant factors to be taken into account in assessing the likelihood of confusion, to the extent that such fame may influence the relevant public’s perception of the trademark (Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of June 24, 2010, Becker v. Harman International Industries, C-51/09 P, EU:C:2010:368, paragraph 37). This implies that the General Court reasonably found that Lionel Messi’s reputation constituted a relevant factor in establishing a conceptual distinction between the terms “messi” and “massi.”
  3. Similarly, the General Court holds that—in response to the appellant’s argument that the General Court relied on facts and evidence presented to it for the first time—Lionel Messi’s reputation was already part of the subject matter of the dispute before EUIPO.

Furthermore, the General Court adds that the General Advocate rightly stated that, given that the notoriety of the surname “Messi”—as the surname of a world-famous soccer player and public figure—was a well-known fact, it could be known to anyone or easily ascertained using accessible sources. Those sources were available to EUIPO when it adopted its decision, and EUIPO should have taken them into account when analyzing the conceptual similarity between the MESSI and MASSI trademarks.

  1. Finally, the Court of Justice determined that the appellant misinterpreted the judgment in Ruiz Picasso et al. v. OHIM (C-361/04 P), since the appellant argued in his appeal brief that the General Court had held that, under certain circumstances, conceptual differences can offset the visual and phonetic similarities between the signs in question.

In this regard, the Court of Justice notes that the global assessment of the likelihood of confusion implies that conceptual differences between two signs may counteract the visual and phonetic similarities between them, provided that at least one of those signs has, from the perspective of the relevant public, a clear and specific meaning, such that the relevant public can grasp it immediately. Therefore, given that the relevant public would perceive the signs at issue (MESSI and MASSI) as two conceptually different signs, the application of the judgment in Ruiz Picasso et al. v. OHIM (C-361/04 P) was correct.

The message conveyed by the Court of Justice in this case—in our view, quite correctly—is clear: regardless of the visual and phonetic similarities between two trademarks, there may be no likelihood of confusion if there is a marked conceptual distinction between them; therefore, Article 8(1)(b) does not apply.

This marked conceptual difference in the present case is based on the fact that the Argentine star’s surname enjoys widespread recognition among the relevant public—a well-known fact that must be taken into account so that the later trademark may be registered despite the existence of earlier MASSI trademarks. It seems obvious that, were the surname “Messi” not so well-known, the trademarks “MESSI” and “MASSI” would clearly be incompatible, and therefore the trademark application at issue here should have been denied.

The question we must now ask ourselves is whether the Court of Justice’s reasoning applies to cases in which the applicant’s trademark is not a “personality” trademark, but rather a trademark that already enjoys a high degree of recognition and awareness among the relevant public as a result of its use in the market. In other words, could a trademark’s reputation be considered a well-known fact by EUIPO, such that the acquired distinctiveness of the applied-for trademark should be regarded as a relevant factor when analyzing the likelihood of confusion with respect to prior trademarks?

We'll have to wait and see what direction EUIPO's practice takes from now on in this regard.

Author: Manuel Mínguez

Previously published in Economist & Jurist

 

"Good morning, Myanmar"

After a few months of inactivity regarding Myanmar’s new Trademark Law—likely due to the COVID-19 pandemic—it appears that the law is finally gaining momentum. The law provides for a procedure known as the “Soft Opening Period” to allow owners who hold acquired rights to their marks in this country to register their trademarks on a priority basis. Our firm has been providing regular updates on the development of this law and this procedure. You can read previous posts on our blog by clicking on the following links:

Myanmar "Soft Opening Period"

 

Since the law took effect on January 31, 2019, there have been several attempts to launch the office and begin its operations. So far, all of them have been thwarted for one reason or another. The challenge of creating a trademark office from scratch in a country like Myanmar, combined with the unfortunate global situation resulting from the spread of COVID-19 so far in 2020, has caused a significant halt and delay in this ambitious project.

Well, following the successive failed announcements of the start of the “Soft Opening period”— first last January and then in April—the Burmese authorities have announced a new start date for the process. If no unforeseen circumstances derail the government’s plans, this expedited procedure for registering acquired rights will begin on October 1, 2020.

We would like to remind you that the new trademark law introduces the “first to file” registration principle . To avoid prejudicing the rights acquired by trademark owners whose trademarks have already been used in the Burmese market and/or who have complied with the formal requirements previously available for the protection of trademarks in this country, those who meet the relevant conditions will have six months, from October 1 through March 31, 2021, to file for their trademark rights with the trademark office. Once the “Soft Opening Period” ends, registration will be open to any interested party.

The preferred procedure is intended for:

  • Holders of declarations registered in the “Declaration of Ownership at the ORD.”
  • Proprietors who have used their trademarks and have sufficient evidence to prove it (for example, publication of preliminary injunctions in newspapers).

ELZABURU has been monitoring the new trademark law since its inception and has a network of local colleagues who provide ongoing updates and information. As a result, we are prepared to assist our clients in protecting their distinctive signs in this country, now as trademark rights.

 

Author: Cristina Arroyo